Skip to content

Tomorrow’s AGM at Celtic Park will be a very peaceful affair for the board. But have they really earned their peace?

Share

Tomorrow’s AGM at Celtic Park will be a very peaceful affair for the board. But have they really earned their peace?

As many of my readers will know, I’ve never been afraid to call out the Celtic Board when circumstances necessitate it.

For a long time during the summer, myself, Joe McHugh, and James Forrest aimed very accurate fire at the board for their level of inaction in that summer transfer window.

We hit the target squarely many times.

In doing so, Peter Lawwell even became upset at the intense daily barrage he was receiving.

As a result, James had to take down one article in particular.

Fortunately for me, I got to see it, but many people who would have liked to, didn’t.

It hit one nerve too many for Peter Lawwell, and he decided freedom of speech, and freedom of opinion, was not something we bloggers were entitled to.

Needless to say, that is now in the past, and it certainly didn’t stop us from voicing our opinions thereafter.

So, as we approach tomorrow’s AGM at Celtic Park, many would see everything as harmonious at the club.

Craig Williamson - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

We’re top of the league, with a Cup final around the corner, and we’re progressing well in this season’s Champions League.

We’ve little or nothing to complain about at the moment, right?

And as a result the board should be in for an easy ride?

Well, let’s just say the current ceasefire is one that is delicately poised.

It could go one way or the other.

But that’s entirely up to the board.

You see, we Celtic fans always want to see our club as something that is ever-evolving.

When we gain momentum like we are now, we want that momentum to continue.

We always want bigger and better for Celtic.

Roddy Scott - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

More often than not, our board hasn’t seen it that way.

No doubt, they feel they vindicated themselves with their big spending at the end of the last window.

And while we spent big, and we’ve definitely seen the benefits of that with quality the new recruits have brought to the squad, there’s always that underlying fear that the board will think that pushing the boat out the way they did last summer was a once off.

We’ve seen of late that Brendan Rodgers almost has two squads at his disposal.

There’s no doubting this is a great position to be in.

But does it also mean that we will have a similar January transfer window to last year’s?

Some might say, considering the current state of play, that two recruits would be more than enough.

Another striker, and Lennon Miller?

And it might be enough.

But would it be enough if Celtic were to have an extended run in the Champions League?

Visionhaus/Getty Images Sport

Which is looking more and more likely now.

Should we be thinking along the lines of strengthening to ensure continued participation in that competition?

Are the board willing to continue to match the ambitions of Brendan Rodgers?

I guess that’s just the way I’m thinking, but the question is, are the board thinking that way?

Surely, being the bean counters they are, they can see the benefits of an extended run in the Champions League?

Is smashing the transfer record again a realistic prospect?

Or will we have to wait another 6 years for that to happen?

You see, that’s the worry you have as a Celtic fan.

You wonder if complacency will eke it’s way back into the mindset of the board.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Or you worry if somebody comes calling with big bucks in January for the likes of Nicholas Kühn, would they be tempted to accept?

Our expectations as fans have evolved based on what happened in the summer, and what we see currently happening on the field of play.

But will those evolving expectations continue to be met?

You would imagine that these are the kinds of questions that should be put to the board tomorrow.

Being under no pressure whatsoever tomorrow, will the likes of Michael Nicholson answer questions honestly?

Or will shareholders get the usual obfuscation and vague responses they get every year?

The Record did an article this morning on 6 burning questions for the board.

It pretty much covers much of the subjects I’ve already talked about, but one point in particular made me laugh, see below:

Somewhere, there will be a rather pleased Celtic fan who reckons they played a key role behind the £19m quadruple splurge in deadline week which landed Arne Engels, Auston Trusty, Luke McCowan and Alex Valle. But, let’s be frank, the wheels were in motion for the champions to finish the window with a bang long before the chairman was challenged to “get the f******* money spent” by an irate punter outside St Mirren’s stadium. Peter said ‘calm doon’ and has been proven correct.

But now comes the interesting bit, the stick or twist element fans will be hoping the answer is the latter. Punters want £11m signings such as Engels to become the norm, a trend-setting strategy which sees Celtic buy at a higher price and, consequently, cash in for fees beyond the almost £30m they will rake in for Matt O’Riley. Lawwell and chief executive Nicholson will be directly asked if smashing their transfer record will become the norm.

Peter said ‘calm doon’ and has been proven correct?

Well, that’s up for debate.

Was he really proven correct?

Craig Williamson - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Or did the board eventually cave in to the pressure from the fans, who towards the end of the summer window, were at the end of their tether?

We’ll never really know for sure.

But the fact that the transfer record was broken twice leaves two questions.

Was it broken because we had every intention of breaking it?

Or was it broken because we left things too late, and the clubs we bought from were able to name their price?

I said Norwich City took the piss.

And I said they did that because the piss was taken out of them with our initial offer for Adam Idah.

Lets hope that lessons were learned in that window, and that the January window is an example of smart business.

Smart business which insulates us and makes us more robust for the very real possibility of an extended run in the Champions League.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

One question that will no doubt be asked tomorrow will be in relation to the Main stand.

It generally always does crop up.

I think fans will be disappointed with the answer though, as I don’t see it happening any time soon.

Then again, our majority shareholder, who is now worth £2 billion, could surely foot the bill?

It would be a drop in the ocean to his finances.

And think of the return he’d get on his investment?

Just like the return he’s gotten on his investment in the club way back in the 90’s?

I don’t understand how he wouldn’t see it as a smart move?

It would guarantee another 20,000 season tickets, about £10 million or more in extra revenue every year.

In another 20 years, Dermot Desmond would have made a fortune out of that investment.

Ewan Bootman - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Either way, there’s no doubting the board are in for an easy ride tomorrow.

To be fair, they’ve never really been given a rough enough ride in the past.

So I’m sure they’ll really be looking forward to tomorrows outing.

Everybody will be dying to see what gags Michael Nicholson has got up his sleeve.

Who knows?

Maybe himself and Pistol Pete will become a comedy duo?

Tomorrow will be a peaceful affair for them.

Have they earned that peace?

For now maybe.

But January is only just around the corner.

Hostilities could resume very quickly.

That’s just the way it is at Celtic.

Fans will always want bigger and better.

One wonders if we now have a board who see it that way too.

I guess that remains to be seen…

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.