Skip to content

Celtic controversy exposes the penalty rule nobody can explain

Share

Celtic controversy exposes the penalty rule nobody can explain

Celtic controversy exposes the penalty rule nobody can explain

Scottish football’s latest penalty controversy has exposed a remarkable problem with VAR. And Celtic supporters have every reason to question whether the rules are being applied consistently.

Willie Collum has defended the controversial penalty awarded to the Ibrox club against St Mirren.

Yet the SFA’s head of refereeing also acknowledged something extraordinary.

Had referee Nick Walsh waved play on, VAR would have supported that decision too.

Two completely different outcomes. The same incident. Both apparently acceptable.

How can that possibly inspire confidence?

Celtic fans deserve an explanation

The incident occurred during Rangers’ 2-0 victory over St Mirren.

James Penrice went down following a challenge from Samuel Ramos. Walsh awarded the penalty, which Ryan Naderi converted.

However, replays sparked considerable debate over the amount of contact involved.

As Glasgow World reported on November 14, Collum defended the referee’s decision.

He explained that the defender had made contact without winning the ball.

Fair enough. That’s his interpretation.

But Collum also confirmed that VAR would not have intervened had the referee allowed play to continue.

Think about that.

A penalty can be awarded. Or not awarded.

And apparently neither decision warrants correction.

Celtic know the cost of refereeing mistakes

Celtic supporters don’t need reminding what happens when officials get important decisions wrong.

During February’s defeat against Hibernian, Liam Scales was pulled inside the penalty area by Jack Iredale.

No penalty was awarded.

Willie Collum subsequently acknowledged that Celtic should have received a spot-kick and that VAR should have recommended a review.

That incident was examined in our recent Read Celtic investigation into the SFA’s refereeing standards.

And here’s the problem.

One club receives a penalty following disputed contact, with the decision defended.

Celtic were denied a penalty for holding, with the decision subsequently acknowledged as incorrect.

These aren’t identical incidents, and the VAR threshold explains why some subjective decisions stand.

But supporters are entitled to ask whether that threshold is delivering acceptable results.

Is VAR protecting decisions rather than correcting them?

The Scotsman group’s coverage of Collum’s latest review also examined the challenges involving Penrice and Celtic youngster Colby Donovan.

Collum supported the yellow-card decisions in those incidents, although he believed Penrice should have been cautioned for his challenge against Aberdeen.

So this isn’t about pretending every decision favours one club.

It’s about demanding standards that supporters can understand.

VAR was introduced to reduce serious mistakes.

Instead, Scottish football increasingly finds itself debating whether officials can justify contradictory outcomes.

And while the explanations keep coming, the consequences remain.

Celtic deserve consistency, not another excuse

Nobody is demanding that VAR overturn every marginal decision.

But when the same incident can produce two opposite outcomes, the system clearly leaves enormous room for interpretation.

That should concern every supporter, regardless of allegiance.

The SFA needs to explain how it measures consistency, how referees improve and why admitted mistakes continue to occur.

Because Celtic supporters are tired of hearing explanations after the points have already been affected.

The question isn’t whether Willie Collum can defend a decision.

It’s whether Scottish football can trust the standards behind it.

Key takeaways

  • Willie Collum defended Rangers’ controversial penalty against St Mirren.
  • Collum acknowledged VAR would also have supported a decision to play on.
  • Celtic were previously denied a penalty against Hibernian that the SFA later accepted should have been awarded.
  • VAR’s clear-and-obvious-error threshold remains central to the controversy.
  • Celtic supporters deserve transparent and consistent refereeing standards.

Further reading

Jump to comments

Phil Cooney I'm 52 years old and from Coatbridge, and Celtic has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Supporting the club isn't just a hobby for me – it's part of who I am. My first visit to Celtic Park came in 1985 against St Mirren, and from that day I was hooked. Like so many supporters of my generation, I grew up idolising Paul McStay. His loyalty, class and ability made him my favourite player, and he remains the player who best represents what Celtic means to me. The Centenary Season will always hold a special place in my heart. Watching Billy McNeill lead the club to that unforgettable league title is a memory I'll never forget, and it's still the benchmark for what Celtic should strive to be. Through this site I write as a supporter first and foremost. I'll praise the club when praise is deserved, but I won't shy away from questioning decisions or expressing concerns when I believe standards have slipped. My aim is to offer honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and passionate discussion on everything happening at Celtic. Whether it's transfer news, match analysis, or the bigger issues surrounding the club, I write from the perspective of someone who has lived and breathed Celtic for over four decades. Hail Hail.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.