Celtic sit four points clear at the top of the Scottish Premiership. Rangers are second, with a game in hand. Yet somehow, listening to Kris Boyd and Hugh Keevins, you would think the champions were approaching footballing Armageddon.
Welcome to another extraordinary episode of Scottish football punditry, where the league table apparently becomes an optional extra whenever Celtic are involved.
Boyd predicts a crisis – Keevins joins the chorus
In comments reported by GlasgowWorld, Boyd suggested Celtic were a club where a crisis always appeared to be around the corner.
Then along came Keevins.
Writing in the Daily Record, the veteran columnist enthusiastically embraced Boyd’s assessment, describing Celtic as unhappy and dysfunctional.
How wonderfully convenient.
Two familiar voices, one familiar narrative, and apparently not a moment’s hesitation about the rather awkward detail that Celtic are actually leading the championship.
The league table refuses to cooperate
Nobody sensible is pretending Celtic have been magnificent.
Performances have disappointed. Recruitment deserves scrutiny. The relationship between supporters and the board has deteriorated alarmingly.
Those are legitimate concerns, and Celtic supporters have been considerably more articulate in identifying them than either pundit gives them credit for.
But there is a considerable difference between constructive criticism and repeatedly forecasting disaster.
Boyd acknowledges Celtic’s four-point advantage before returning to his preferred crisis narrative.
Keevins goes further, effectively presenting Celtic’s internal disagreements as evidence that their title defence is approaching catastrophe.
Meanwhile, the Ibrox club’s improved form receives a far more optimistic interpretation.
One club’s difficulties become an impending collapse. The other’s become evidence of an exciting revival.
Funny how that works.
Celtic supporters don’t need lectures
What makes this particularly tiresome is the assumption that Celtic supporters cannot distinguish between dissatisfaction and disaster.
We can criticise Dermot Desmond, question Michael Nicholson, demand better recruitment and still recognise that Martin O’Neill’s side are top of the league.
These positions are not contradictory.
Indeed, supporters demanding higher standards while their team leads the championship might reasonably be described as ambitious.
Instead, Boyd and Keevins seem determined to interpret every Celtic problem as confirmation of their preferred storyline.
The predictions are becoming embarrassing
Rangers deserve recognition for improving under Derek McInnes. Their game in hand matters, and this title race is far from settled.
But improvement is not achievement. Optimism is not a trophy. And predictions are not league points.
Perhaps Boyd and Keevins should spend less time anticipating Celtic’s downfall and more time explaining why the supposedly dysfunctional champions remain ahead of the club they are so eager to celebrate.
Until the table changes, their crisis narrative looks less like penetrating analysis and more like wishful thinking dressed up as expertise.
Celtic are top. Rangers are chasing.
For all the dramatic pronouncements, those remain the facts.
Key takeaways
- Celtic remain four points clear despite Boyd and Keevins highlighting the possibility of a crisis.
- Supporters’ legitimate criticism of the Celtic board should not be confused with surrendering the title race.
- Rangers’ improvement deserves recognition, but their challenge must be judged by results.
- The contrasting media narratives deserve serious scrutiny.














Comments.
Loading comments…