Skip to content

Is Don Robertson the most inept Scottish referee of all time, or is he just “inept” when it comes to Celtic?

Share

Is Don Robertson the most inept Scottish referee of all time, or is he just “inept” when it comes to Celtic?

I decided to once again delve into where Celtic were this time last year, to compare it to where we find ourselves right now.

Ironically, this time a year ago, give or take a couple of days, we played the exact same home fixture as we did last Sunday.

Coincidentally enough, that game happened to be all about the referee’s performance too.

Imagine that?

So bad was Don Robertson’s performance in a relatively straightforward 4-0 victory over Kilmarnock last year, that I decided to dedicate an article to him.

John Beaton had plenty dedicated to him this time around, but it was the infamous ‘sailing through the air and making contact with nobody at all’ incident in this one that drew all the attention to it.

And it left me asking the question, is Don Robertson the worst Scottish referee of all time?

Well, it’s a close run thing between him and Beaton after last Sunday, but for downright ineptitude, I still think Robertson still shades it.

Enjoy last year’s homage to him.

I know I enjoyed writing it….

Don Robertson, magician extraordinaire, a man capable of creating yellow cards out of thin air.

I think you catch my drift when I refer to thin air?

Because that’s what seems to be between Celtic players and the players they’ve allegedly assaulted when Robertson hands out his magical yellow cards.

One never imagined he’d best his Alex Schalk magic trick from 2017, but somehow he did.

Yesterday, Daizen Maeda performed a ninja like attempt at blocking a clearance from Killie defender James Brown.

As he sailed gracefully through thin air, making zero contact whatsoever with Brown, I’m guessing the updraft, gale of wind, vortex, whatever you want to call it, turned the helpless Brown upside down.

In Don Robertson’s book, this warrants a yellow card.

Just ask Alex Schalk.

Yes, “Der Bomber von Breda” was on the receiving end of one of those very vortex inducing tackles from Erik Sviatchenko back in 2017.

(Photo by Craig Foy/SNS Group via Getty Images)

I’m not sure he ever recovered properly from it.

Don Robertson magicked up a yellow card for that one, and a penalty to boot!

But in all seriousness, what an absolute joke of a decision yesterday.

It seems there are no limits to the level of blunder Robertson is capable of making.

Which begs the question, is he officially the most inept Scottish referee of all time?

Or is his ineptitude only prevalent around Celtic, if you catch my drift?

Well, miraculously yesterday, the team that had 74.7% of the possession managed to commit 14 fouls.

Whereas the team that only had 25.3% only committed 4 fouls

Imagine that?

Now, in a football league where you have professional referees who have to go through the misfortune of declaring their allegiances, (I know, can you believe that?!), something entirely different happens in games like yesterday’s.

Usually, the team with the most possession is the team that commits the least fouls.

This is because the team with less possession is doing all of the chasing to get the ball, and invariably, this results in them committing more fouls.

The opposite seems to be the case in Scotland, or more to the point, in games when Celtic are playing.

The pattern always seems to be that while Celtic has the majority of the possession, we still commit more fouls than the opposition.

In our last three home fixtures, where we had the majority of the possession in all three fixtures, but the foul counts were as follows:

Celtic 17 – Motherwell 12

Celtic 14 – Falkirk 12

Celtic 14 – Kilmarnock 4

Note that the Kilmarnock game was refereed by Robertson…

To give an example of how professional, unbiased referees perform, I picked a game from the EPL over the weekend to test this theory.

Aston Villa defeated Bournemouth by the same margin we defeated Kilmarnock.

Aston Villa had more possession than Bournemouth in this game, so have a guess what the foul count was?

20 fouls to Bournemouth, and 8 to Aston Villa.

Villa were the team in ascendency, as the result reflects, so Bournemouth constantly had to chase them in this game.

As a result, they committed a lot more fouls than Villa.

That’s pretty much how it should play out.

So let’s go back to the candidate for Scotland’s worst referee and his alleged ineptitude.

Is it really ineptitude or a pattern of assistance, though?

To conclude, I’ll leave you with this.

When we played out a nil-all draw with Hibs at the end of September, Robertson was once again the referee.

The foul count?

Celtic 16 – Hibs 1

Celtic had 77.4% possession.

Ineptitude or intention?

Which is it?

I mean, I’d like to say that Robertson is the most inept referee in Scotland, but something tells me he isn’t really.

Something tells me he just doesn’t like Celtic.

Want one more?

Celtic 1-0 St. Mirren, once again Celtic had 77% of the possession, and the foul count?

Celtic 10 – St. Mirren 6.

I could keep going because this pattern is prevalent in every game Robertson referees involving Celtic.

Maybe he’s not so stupid after all….

Key Takeaways

  • The article compares Celtic’s performance this year to last year, particularly focusing on referee Don Robertson’s controversial decisions.
  • Robertson’s questionable officiating raises the question of whether he is the worst Scottish referee of all time, especially in matches involving Celtic.
  • Statistics show a pattern where Celtic commits more fouls despite having the majority of possession during Robertson’s refereeing.
  • Incidents from past games highlight Robertson’s inconsistencies, leading to speculation about his impartiality towards Celtic.
  • The writer suggests that Robertson’s decisions may not just be ineptitude, but possibly intentional bias against Celtic.

Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.