Skip to content

Celtic promise answers at the AGM — will Desmond finally deliver them?

Share

Celtic promise answers at the AGM — will Desmond finally deliver them?

Celtic AGM answers should be the minimum shareholders expect on 1 December. Yet Brian Wilson’s promise of explanations now leaves this board facing a test it cannot satisfy with another polished speech.

In Celtic’s AGM announcement, the interim chairman said: “The shareholders have every right to be heard, to challenge, to question and to be given information and explanations.”

Good. Now apply that standard to Dermot Desmond.

I find it extraordinary that asking a director to face shareholders personally has become a campaign in itself. An accountable board should welcome that expectation without needing supporters to organise around it.

Celtic AGM answers must come from Desmond

The formal AGM notice puts Desmond’s reappointment before shareholders. That makes the question particularly sharp: why should anyone renew their confidence without hearing his case directly?

A representative can communicate a position. Only Desmond can answer follow-up questions about his own judgement, priorities and influence.

As we argued in our examination of Desmond’s AGM attendance, that distinction matters.

The Celtic Fans Collective’s appeal, reported by GlasgowWorld, captures it: “With that influence comes a responsibility to be accountable.”

Precisely. Respect for a shareholder’s investment cannot become permanent exemption from uncomfortable questions.

Desmond is a shareholder and director. Celtic is not his private possession, and its supporters are entitled to challenge the direction he supports.

A board asking for trust should offer evidence

However, this responsibility extends across the table. Michael Nicholson and his fellow directors must explain their decisions in terms shareholders can assess.

What are Celtic’s football priorities? Who takes responsibility when recruitment falls short? What would make the board change its approach?

Resolution 16 offers a concrete starting point: a proposed three-to-five-year football, financial and strategic plan with measurable goals.

Shareholders should ask each director whether they support that proposal and why. General assurances about ambition cannot answer a specific question about how progress will be measured.

As our earlier AGM piece argued, arranging a meeting only creates the opportunity for accountability. The answers determine whether it happens.

In my view, a boardroom culture that expects renewed trust without clear tests of performance has become complacent. Celtic deserve far more demanding leadership.

The board cannot mark its own homework

Of course, shareholders should let speakers finish. Precise questions and persistent follow-ups will expose weak answers more effectively than a room nobody can hear.

However, an orderly meeting places an equal obligation on the directors: answer the question asked.

Wilson should ensure clear responses, identify who owns each commitment and set dates for any outstanding information.

I have no interest in another ceremonial exercise where directors congratulate themselves and supporters leave carrying the same doubts.

If this board wants renewed confidence, it must earn it under scrutiny.

Will Desmond face the room and help deliver the Celtic AGM answers Wilson has promised?

Jump to comments

Phil Cooney I'm 52 years old and from Coatbridge, and Celtic has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Supporting the club isn't just a hobby for me – it's part of who I am. My first visit to Celtic Park came in 1985 against St Mirren, and from that day I was hooked. Like so many supporters of my generation, I grew up idolising Paul McStay. His loyalty, class and ability made him my favourite player, and he remains the player who best represents what Celtic means to me. The Centenary Season will always hold a special place in my heart. Watching Billy McNeill lead the club to that unforgettable league title is a memory I'll never forget, and it's still the benchmark for what Celtic should strive to be. Through this site I write as a supporter first and foremost. I'll praise the club when praise is deserved, but I won't shy away from questioning decisions or expressing concerns when I believe standards have slipped. My aim is to offer honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and passionate discussion on everything happening at Celtic. Whether it's transfer news, match analysis, or the bigger issues surrounding the club, I write from the perspective of someone who has lived and breathed Celtic for over four decades. Hail Hail.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.