Skip to content

Collum’s party political broadcast on behalf of the SFA obfuscates and side-steps the real issues when it comes to declaring Ibrox or Celtic allegiances

Share

Collum’s party political broadcast on behalf of the SFA obfuscates and side-steps the real issues when it comes to declaring Ibrox or Celtic allegiances

Willie Collum was wheeled out on Clyde 1 the other evening to give us his refreshing honesty and transparency when it comes to Scottish refereeing.

Now, yours and my definition of honesty and transparency, and his definition of honesty and transparency, seem to be two completely different things.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying that Willie Collum is deliberately bullshitting people, but what I am saying is that he’s not being entirely honest with people either.

If his intention is to be honest, then he has a long way to go before people start to trust him, and his “top” referees.

So, let’s look at the starting point for Collum.

Right now, nobody outside the SFA trusts the way the game is refereed in Scotland.

This is not conjecture, it is simply a fact.

We are only four games into the current season, and there have been a myriad of controversial decisions already.

Collum had the opportunity to debate the majority of these decisions, but it seems he decided to pick and choose what he would and wouldn’t talk about.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

It was as if a decision was made along the lines of, okay, we’ll admit we got some things wrong, but we won’t talk about some of the most controversial decisions.

Namely the decision not to award a penalty to Hearts on the opening day of the season after a blatant handball by Conor Barron.

Followed by the the goal Celtic were denied by Andrew Dallas in the Glasgow Derby.

Of course, that one could not be discussed simply because it would highlight the inadequacies of our third rate VAR system.

Which is clearly used to give us a vague idea of what is termed as offside and what is not.

Now, I could go on all day about these decisions, it isn’t going to change them.

What I’m more interested in was the way that Collum dealt with the age old question of allegiances.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Or “declarations of interest”, as he put it.

So what exactly is a declaration of interest in refereeing terms?

Well, its to make known one’s connection, especially a prejudicial connection with any club, which may affect a referee’s decision making.

Here’s what Collum had to say on this particular subject in his interview:

First of all, referees need to declare an interest. We had a top assistant a couple of years ago and his son was playing for a senior club, even though he was playing for an under-19 club he declared that as an interest. Also, if somebody is working for a company that sponsors a particular club, these are the things we would expect the referee to declare an interest in.

My reading of this is that Collum is saying there is a policy in place at the SFA, where referees need to declare an interest when it comes to who they support.

But here’s where I get confused, if this is the policy, then it is clearly not adhered to in any way, shape, or form.

What makes Collum’s comments open to interpretation are the following words in that segment, need and expect.

Insert the word must into where he says need, and then insert the word stipulate into where he says expect.

Then you have something that looks like set policy and a rule, rather than something that is open to debate.

Which is exactly what I’m doing.

To need something is to require it.

To expect something is to regard something as likely to happen.

Meaning its open to interpretation, and isn’t exactly set in stone, i.e., it isn’t exactly a rule.

Confused yet?

Well, whether Collum is intending to or not, he is confusing people.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

This next segment of Collum’s explanation on allegiances is vague to the point of obfuscation.

I genuinely think he’s trying to make his answer totally unclear and unintelligible.

Have a look at this:

In terms of a team that somebody might support or a connection with a family member, where do we draw the line? We want to encourage people into refereeing and say you can referee the top games – you can referee the top games. We would put a blocker on that, and I keep saying where do you draw the line?

The answer to his first question in relation to a team that somebody supports is simple.

There is no need for any confusion here at all.

The answer is they do not referee any games involving the team they support.

Its that simple.

That’s how it works in the EPL, so why can’t it work that way in the Scottish Premiership.

However, if Collum gave that answer, then that would be a clear indication there is a rule in place regarding such things.

Which we now know there clearly isn’t.

Collum’s next sentence is complete gobble-de-gook, I don’t think he even knows what he’s saying himself.

Octavio Passos/Getty Images Sport

Well, either that, or he knows exactly what he’s saying, I’ll let you be the judge of that.

We want to encourage people into refereeing and say you can referee the top games – you can referee the top games.

In other words, it doesn’t matter if you support Celtic or the Ibrox club, you can referee these games.

But we expect you to declare an interest, just so we know, of course, and can ensure that those who support the Ibrox club get to referee more derby games than those who support Celtic, or anyone else for that matter.

Think I’m being a conspiracy theorist with that theory?

Collum had the perfect opportunity to dispel the belief that Ibrox supporting referees are continually given preference over Celtic supporting refs, or refs with no allegiance to either side when it comes to derby games, by doing just one thing.

Not appointing two Ibrox supporting refs in Beaton and Dallas to take charge of that fixture.

Giving the excuse that Beaton is one of the “top referees” in the game, and that’s why he gets those fixtures is bullshit.

He is one of the worst referees in the game.

A man who Brendan Rodgers termed as incompetent.

And yet it is he who referees more derby games than anyone else.

It is also crystal clear where his allegiances lie, along with the man who was VAR in that fixture.

Alan Harvey - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Then the statement, we would put a blocker on that, and I keep saying where do you draw the line?

What the hell does that even mean??

Put a blocker on what??

Who can and can’t referee games involving certain teams?

You’ll need to be a bit more clear than that Willie.

Collum’s next statement is the same old story we’re always fed.

Always fed, and expected to believe.

Except its impossible to believe, and only those within the ranks of the SFA believe it, because its convenient to do so:

If somebody’s third relative had a connection somewhere, or had a season ticket to support somebody – what I would say is, and I want to be really honest with people, when you are refereeing at the top level of the game you have a passion for it, you want to achieve well. Refereeing took me places as a young kid that I never dreamed I would go to. Why would I jeopardise or risk that to say ‘I want this team to win or affect this’ – I want people to trust me that it’s not the case.

Okay Willie, so let me get this straight?

If I’m John Beaton and I support the Ibrox club, I promise I’ll be on my best behaviour as a referee.

I’m passionate and I want to achieve well.

Why would I jeopardise or risk that to say ‘I want this team to win or affect this?’

Because there are no repercussions if you do, or you don’t, there never have been.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

John Beaton has neither jeopardised nor risked anything by being an utter incompetent, so how does Willie Collum expect people to “trust him that it’s not the case”??

Nor do I think he could care less about where refereeing might take him, he is rarely, if ever, chosen to referee on the international stage.

That in itself speaks volumes in relation to his character, and his refereeing ability.

This whole spiel becomes easier and easier to take apart as it continues:

We are barraged by comments in the west of Scotland towards one club or the other – that is not the case. People make genuine decisions, genuine errors and we are honest. If referees weren’t honest we would have a problem. It’s 2024, I think we need to move away from that. I would ask people to shift that narrative, let’s get behind referees rather than try to pick a fault because a person is associated with that or that. They are top referees for a reason and it’s been a long journey to get there. And when they get there they want to stay there.

If referees weren’t honest we would have a problem?

You do have a problem Willie, and it’s your job to fix it, not defend it.

It doesn’t make a difference if its 2024 or not, we will never move away from this issue unless its dealt with properly.

You have a chance to reform refereeing in the Scottish game, but you’re choosing instead to defend this bollocks.

We can’t shift the narrative.

We can’t get behind referees just because you say we should.

Alan Harvey - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Its impossible not to pick a fault because a person is associated with that or that.

That’s like asking Ibrox supporters to give Philippe Clement time.

Same old story, different context, just as the Ibrox club won’t change, clearly neither will refereeing in the Scottish game.

Finally, Collum gives it the coup de grace, the ultimate finish, and a masterclass on how to get nobody involved in supporting the Scottish game behind you in your new role:

I think it is insulting because it is questioning people’s integrity. Referees integrity is alway at the utmost. What I would say as well is people say geographically a referee comes from here, or comes from there and has a background as I mentioned earlier – I don’t care about any of these things. I want quality, and that is what we (the SFA) judge referees on.

That statement is an insult to our collective intelligence’s as Scottish football supporters.

The integrity of Scottish referees has always been under the microscope.

Collum had an opportunity to change perceptions, but he’s choosing to brazen it out instead.

He’s basically saying he doesn’t care who his referees support, its never going to change.

He’s basically saying that he is turning a blind eye to unconscious bias, and he doesn’t care about that either.

He wants quality, and that is what the SFA judges referees on.

Except that they don’t judge them.

When they make mind boggling decisions, which favour one club, and marginalise another, they are never questioned.

Never judged.

Never held accountable.

We were naïve to think this man would bring about change in Scottish refereeing.

Jean Catuffe/Getty Images Sport

He’s just made it blatantly clear that he won’t be.

Collum started by saying that referees had to declare an interest.

Then he went on to say their interests don’t really matter, cos they’re just all round, honest to God, good guys.

And then he finished by saying if we question their integrity, we’re insulting them.

So basically, put up, and shut up.

Complete obfuscation, whereby he answered absolutely nothing of note.

Other than to say in a roundabout way nothing is changing.

Nothing will change.

And people wonder why the Scottish game is considered tinpot?

There’s you answer in a nutshell.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.