Skip to content

“If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people things they do not want to hear.” The Celtic hierarchy should pay close attention to that Orwell quote

Share

“If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people things they do not want to hear.” The Celtic hierarchy should pay close attention to that Orwell quote

There was a seismic shift in Celtic cyberspace yesterday.

For the first time since I became interested in the online Celtic community, a blogger was asked to remove an opinion piece.

We all know the blogger in question.

And we all know why he was asked to remove the piece in question.

So, why was he targeted?

What was it he said that was so bad that he was threatened in the way he was if he didn’t remove it?

In order to understand that, we need to look at a few different things.

In the Celtic blogosphere, there are several different factions.

Stu Forster/Getty Images Sport

The first faction are the clickbait merchants.

These are the kind of bloggers who name sites like Football Fancast or Football Insider as their sources.

They write blogs based on info provided by websites who know nothing whatsoever about what’s going on at Celtic.

Using a headline that draws you in, you will then get into the story and learn absolutely nothing you didn’t know already.

They are not interested in Celtic, rather, they are interested in what they can make out of Celtic.

Then there’s the second faction, they are the happy clappers.

Personally, I have no issue with these guys.

They report good news stories about Celtic all the time, which is their prerogative.

Jan Kruger - UEFA/UEFA/Getty Images

They choose to ignore the things that frustrate the fans, instead focusing on stories that are designed to make the fanbase happy.

Nothing at all wrong with that.

Other than the fact there is a hell of a lot going on beneath the surface, which they probably know about, but choose to leave to one side.

Ultimately, they choose the path of least resistance.

That is instead, left to likes of the third faction.

I would consider myself part of the third faction.

James Forrest and Joe McHugh are also part of this faction.

We are not afraid to challenge the club.

In doing so, we are not afraid to raise the topics that are a constant bugbear to the more “in tune” Celtic fans out there.

Actually, it is probably more appropriate for me to link the three blogging factions to the factions we have in our fanbase.

The clickbait faction would be linked to the kind of Celtic fans who really only have a passing interest in the club.

They’re not heavily invested in the club, and news of any kind is just news to them.

They go with the flow.

You will often still hear them refer to the Glasgow Derby as the “O** F***.”

Visionhaus/Getty Images Sport

That speaks for itself really.

The happy clappers faction would be linked to Celtic fans who are happy with their lot.

Beating the Ibrox side on a regular basis is enough for them.

As long as they can slag their Ibrox counterparts at work, then that keeps them happy, and amused.

They will consistently hand over the money season after season, without question.

The general consensus amongst these fans is that the board is doing a good job.

The reality is that they don’t really care, and they find it hard to comprehend it when people question the board.

You’ll get, “Well we’re the most financially stable we’ve ever been as a club, what’s the problem?”

Or, “Top class players don’t want to play in Scotland, we have a very small pool to choose from.”

When you ask them what the benefit of having all that money sitting in the bank is, they will struggle to answer you.

Then if you ask them who told them top class players don’t want to come to Scotland, they’ll say, “Well, that’s what the board says, so it must be true.”

In other words, they believe everything that is fed to them by the board.

Stu Forster/Getty Images Sport

Even though the board feeds them very little.

Board = that’s just the way it is.

Any other opinion = you don’t know what you’re talking about.

Believe me, I have many of these goons in my CSC, so I’m talking from experience.

Finally, you have the fans that we, the third faction, reach out to with our blogs.

These types of fans are heavily invested in Celtic.

They have been supporting the club all of their lives.

They’ve been through the hard times, and the good.

If they haven’t been through the hard times, they’ve educated themselves fully on them.

These fans will have an in depth knowledge of the club and it’s machinations.

If you strike up a conversation with them, they will engage with you immediately.

They’ll tell you what they feel is wrong with the club, and how it could be changed.

There is a common denominator amongst all of these fans, they are not happy with the Celtic board.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

They are frustrated beyond belief at the direction the club is headed in.

Or more to the point, the lack of direction at the club.

This element of the fanbase is not huge, but the board knows it is dangerous.

Right now, it is a minor threat, but a threat nonetheless.

The majority of these fans see through the board, and know they are being taken for a ride.

But they persevere out of love for the club.

They consistently talk about not putting their hard-earned cash into the club.

But deep down they know it is a fruitless endeavour, because the happy clappers and the passing interest fans will continue to plough their money into the club.

They are caught between a rock and a hard place.

An emotional battle between their love for the club, and their dislike of the current board.

It is those fans who agree wholeheartedly with what the third blogging faction writes.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

So much so, that they defend us steadfastly, and attempt to educate fans who pour scorn on our opinions.

I fear that this too, is a fruitless endeavour.

However, something happened yesterday.

Something different.

James Forrest, in no uncertain terms, was threatened by an individual at the club.

He was informed if he didn’t remove his opinion piece, he would be sued for libel.

This represents a huge shift in attitude from this individual.

For years now, a blind eye has been turned to what the bloggers have been saying about this individual.

He has never cared.

Because it has altered nothing.

He still gets what he gets from the club.

But something cut very close to the bone yesterday, and there was a clear and obvious concern that what James said could go viral.

As I’ve stated before, we bloggers form our opinions based on the patterns that emerge from how we study the club on a daily basis.

Jan Kruger - UEFA/UEFA/Getty Images

Every day, without fail.

In depth.

I wrote an opinion piece yesterday, which has resulted in huge debate.

It is inevitable that somewhere along the line, our opinion, and make no mistake, it is only ever an opinion, will hit the bullseye.

I think this is what happened yesterday.

However, I would go one further and say that mounting opinions from the third faction have been hitting the mark.

It just so happened that yesterday’s opinion might have been the straw that broke the camel’s back.

The one that could have potentially opened the floodgates.

But inadvertently, through the way it was dealt with, actually did.

Threatening a blogger for having an opinion, however factual, is not a good look.

There is an almost Cybernetic element to it.

An attempt at replacing a living, thinking fan, fighting for his club’s interests, with happy clappers, if you’ll excuse the pun.

This individual wants all fans to be unquestioning automatons, ploughing their money into the club.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

Year in, year out.

Any threat to that affects who though?

Certainly not the fanbase, or even the club, in fact these opinions are aimed at the betterment of the club.

Put simply, only the individual who feels he is being threatened, is threatened.

Nobody else.

How he believes he is being threatened, well, only he knows that.

I opened this article with a quote from George Orwell; if liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people things they do not want to hear.

Celtic has always championed liberty, that can never be disputed, should never be disputed.

The liberty Orwell refers to should never be challenged.

Bettmann/Bettmann/Getty Images

Celtic fans have a right to know what goes on at their club, since they plough an awful lot of their hard earned money into the club.

They have been denied that right for a long time now.

Yesterday signalled the intent to ensure that right will continue to be denied.

I’ve been a Celtic fan throughout four decades now.

If I was to calculate what I’ve spent throughout those decades supporting this club, it would amount to a small fortune.

I am but one.

Multiply that by a full Celtic Park and the figures would be staggering.

Then add the Celtic fanbase throughout the world.

You get where I’m going with this, don’t you?

Respect the lifeblood of the club, and the lifeblood will respect you.

Actions like yesterday’s will never garner any respect.

We can not, and should never become an institution that attempts to take away the liberty to tell people what they do not want to hear.

Because if we go down that road, how will we ever change as a club?

And now, more than ever, this club needs change.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.