So today, I’ve decided to play the conspiracy theorist when it comes to Celtic.
I mean after all, most of the time we bloggers are called exactly that.
We’re accused of speculation, scare mongering, and being conspiracy theorists.
What I would say is that we have theories for the behaviour that goes on at our club.
That doesn’t necessarily make them conspiracy theories, because for there to be a conspiracy going on, there must be a secret plan by a group to do something unlawful or harmful.
The Celtic board are extremely secretive, that cannot be denied.
Sometimes that’s a good thing, and sometimes it’s not.
They definitely aren’t doing anything unlawful.
So, I guess that just leaves harmful.
And the question I’ve got to ask is this; is the board’s current behaviour harmful towards the progress of Celtic football club?

There are two perspectives that you can look at this from.
Firstly, the fans’ perspective.
I am a fan first, a blogger second, and I see everything through the prism of the fanbase.
In a lot of instances, I follow my heart instead of my head when it comes to Celtic.
I get engrossed in the passion and love all of us Celtic fans feel towards the club.
It is a special thing, a raw thing, that many football fans throughout the world do not get to feel.
For us, Celtic is a way of life.
Hell, for me it is a way of life because I write about it every day.
I’ve written three books in my lifetime, but nothing ever supplies me with as much subject matter as Celtic.
Simply because Celtic is a living breathing thing, something that will outlive me, and be there long after I am nothing but ash.

The imprint I make on Celtic will be one of millions throughout the lifetime of the club.
But the imprint Celtic has made on me is unique, and will be with me for the duration of my life.
However, if I take the heartfelt passion and feelings I have for the club out of the equation, in my full time job, I run a business, where at the end of the day, all that matters is the bottom line.
So I understand how a business works.
I also understand how certain business models work.
The company I work for was formed in 1992 from very humble beginnings.
Since then, it has grown into a multi-billion pound operation, operating out of Ireland, the UK and the US.
As a company, it has experienced this kind of growth because the men who founded the company were never afraid to speculate to accumulate.
The bottom line to them, was an opportunity for growth, and they used the profits the company made to continually grow it into the huge operation it is today.
It continues to grow at an exponential rate.
Yes, it is a different kind of business to a football club, but the principles for it’s growth are the very same as those of a football club.
Make profits, invest those profits in the business to help it to grow continuously.
So, with that much said, I will now attempt to look at things from the Celtic board’s perspective.
Peter Lawwell, and all of the men charged with running Celtic football club state that they are, first and foremost, Celtic fans.
If they are Celtic fans, then they must care deeply about the well being of the club, right?
You would certainly like to think so anyway.
As custodians of the club, just like any other business, they are charged with making it profitable, and sustainable.
I think it is fair to say they have achieved that, and then some.
To many people, Celtic is a prime example of a well run business.
Many other football clubs aspire to be like Celtic.
If you were in the board’s shoes, you would be entitled to think you are doing a great job.
You are keeping the football club on a sustainable, healthy footing, all while ensuring the shareholders are kept happy, and also the principle shareholder, Dermot Desmond.

Who ultimately, you answer to.
From the board’s perspective, they feel they are doing exactly what they are paid to do.
And let’s not forget, they are being handsomely paid for their endeavours.
So the board are keeping everybody they are paid to keep happy, including themselves, well…..very happy.
Chapeau to them.
Well done.
But it seems to me they are forgetting about two very important cogs in the machine they run.
Without these two cogs, the machine would grind to a shuddering halt.
What are these two cogs?
Well, you don’t have to be a genius to figure it out.
The Celtic fanbase, and the footballing operation.
Without wanting to sound too cliched, football without the fans is nothing.

We know this because of how that impacted us and our club four years ago.
Without the footballing operation, well, the club simply doesn’t exist.
So I’m going to play devil’s advocate, and put a conspiracy theory out there.
Is it fair to say our board is neglecting the lifeblood of Celtic football club, the fanbase?
Would you say that me stating that is conspiratorial?
And in turn, in addition to neglecting the fanbase, is it fair to say the board is neglecting the football operation?
Are those statements conspiratorial, or are they fact?
Well, here’s the thing, through the eyes of the majority of the fanbase, those statements are fact, because the evidence is there for all to see.
The fanbase consistently hands over it’s hard earned cash to the football club, and in return, the majority of the fanbase feels it’s being short changed.
The fans feel they’re being short changed because the product on the pitch is systematically being weakened season upon season since a certain individual returned to the boardroom.
And there it is!
The ultimate conspiracy theory.
One man is the common denominator behind all of what is wrong at Celtic right now.
I told you I was playing the conspiracy theorist today.
But here’s the thing, Peter Lawwell would look at someone like me, and state that I am exactly that.

A conspiracy theorist.
Because in his mind, he feels he is doing the best he can for Celtic.
But the unfortunately reality is the majority of us just don’t see it from his perspective.
We just don’t see it that way.
And the evidence to the contrary at the moment is overwhelming.
All you need to do is look at the current transfer window.
As I highlighted in yesterday’s article, £1 million spent so far, £3 million into the club’s coffers so far.
We are hurtling headlong into this coming season weaker than we finished the last.
That is a fact, not a conspiracy, and unless it changes radically in a short space of time, it will remain so.
I headlined this article with the question, if the Celtic board are not intent on downsizing, then what is it exactly that they’re doing?
And that’s the £100 million question.
What is it exactly that they’re doing?
Well, the answer to that lies with Peter Lawwell and the people in his boardroom.
I can only theorise about what their thinking might be.
Whether that’s conspiratorial or factual, only time will tell.
Because thus far, this transfer window shows no signs of coming to life in any meaningful way.
David Low, one of the men instrumental in helping to bring Celtic back from the brink in the mid-90s and facilitating Fergus McCann’s takeover, stated that the financial gap between Celtic and the Ibrox side is now at an unhealthy level.

In a recent conversation over on the Celtic Exchange, he asked a very pertinent question when he said this:
What does Mike Tyson get out of sparring with Barry McGuigan? Very little.
That is the perfect metaphor for the position Celtic currently finds itself in now.
But isn’t it all very coincidental David Low has come out with all of that at this particular juncture?
And here’s the conspiracy theorist coming out in me again….
Is this why the board does not want to spend big in this transfer window?
Is it because they know that if they do, it will essentially kill off any competition from the Ibrox side?
Effectively causing Mike Tyson to beat Barry McGuigan into a pulp, so to speak.
And who wants that?
I do, and so does every other Celtic fan out there.
We’ve always wanted it.
But Peter Lawwell and his board feel that something like that would be bad for business.
They’ve always felt that way.
The crisis unfolding over at Ibrox scares them, and make no mistake about it, that club are in a crisis situation at the moment.
The chances are we’ll beat them to a pulp just by standing still and not improving at all this season.
Because they are downsizing, they have no choice now.

Forget our European aspirations, we just can’t be seen to be using our main rivals as a punchbag.
It’s just not good for business.
So I’ll leave you with the question I started this article with.
If the Celtic board are not intent on downsizing, then what is it exactly that they’re doing?
Only Peter Lawwell, and Michael Nicholson et al can give you the answer to that.
But the conspiracy theorist in me, and my gut instinct, is telling me it isn’t good.
If Matt O’Riley is sold, and not adequately replaced, then we are significantly weaker than we were last season.
Just about a match for our main rivals?
Who knows?
But I’ll tell you this much, unless we start to see major signs of life in terms of transfers in the next two weeks, the signs will become very ominous.
I hope I’m proved wrong.
I hope to God my gut instinct is wrong.
But it’s in my Celtic DNA to worry.
And right now, I’m worried.














Comments.
Loading comments…