Skip to content

With £100 million already sitting in the bank, are the Celtic board REALLY intent on making a profit in this transfer window?

Share

With £100 million already sitting in the bank, are the Celtic board REALLY intent on making a profit in this transfer window?

On Tuesday, I wrote an article where I tried to be optimistic in terms of the commencement of our transfer business. As is often the case, my optimism when it comes to the Celtic board is usually short lived.

The reason for this is because I think about things in depth.

On the one hand, I could say that the acquisition of Kaspar Schmeichel and Viljami Sinisalo is genius.

And to a degree, the thinking behind it is very smart.

But on the other hand, it’s only costing us £1 million, and there’s no way Kaspar Schmeichel would be coming to Celtic if there wasn’t a connection with Brendan Rodgers.

It is a very low risk venture, and a very low risk strategy.

It is conservative, and by no means a gamble.

Worst case scenario is Sinisalo doesn’t work out, and Schmeichel covers the role for a season or two.

Then, when he retires, we’re back to square one.

Don’t get me wrong, I know Rodgers is no fool, and I’m sure he’s done his homework on Sinisalo.

Chances are that this will work out for Celtic and the board.

Etsuo Hara/Getty Images Sport

But if it doesn’t, it won’t have cost the club a lot to find out it didn’t.

Because our board is so conservative and risk averse, when you get a situation like what happened with Vasilas Barkas, it would appear they are determined not to make the same mistake again.

Rodgers gave them an out with this one, and they happily took it.

Time will tell how well this works out.

So, while my first impressions of these acquisitions were that it represented joined up thinking, and a smart strategy, once I thought about it deeper….. well, you get what I’m saying?

There is always an underlying strategy to what this board does.

Ultimately it always revolves around saving money.

But I’ve got to ask this question, when does this board and this club get to a position where enough is enough?

The bank balance just continues to grow.

Yet the football squad and it’s ability does not.

And whenever it does, its always stifled, and the valuable assets are always sold off by the board.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

So what’s the end game here?

£300 million?

£400 million?

Half a billion?

When does the bank balance become enough?

I understand that there is always a limited amount of time a talented player will remain in Scotland.

We cannot make talented players stay here against their will, so in the end, they will always go.

However, while I understand this, what I fail to understand is why the large sums we make off these players are never wisely re-invested in the squad in any meaningful way?

Last summer’s transfer window is a perfect example of that.

£25 million for Jota.

£20 million of it invested in projects, in the hopes one or two of them will be another Jota.

The net spend is then less than the amount received for Jota.

Transfer window finishes with a net profit.

Brendan Rodgers then finishes the season using none of the players acquired in that transfer window.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Wise spending?

Or a waste of £20 million?

You tell me.

All of the board apologists who read this will say the same thing over and over again.

“Well, what do you expect? Do you expect us to spend £50 million on transfers just because we have it?”

Or, “Why are you always complaining? We’ve never been as successful as we are under this board!”

Or, “We’re one of the best run clubs in Europe, what’s your problem?”

Firstly, no, I never expect the club to spend £50 million on transfers, just because we have it.

And secondly, a simple counter argument to we’re one of the best run clubs in Europe is this; if we are, then why did we waste £20 million on players who clearly didn’t make the grade last summer?

If we are, then why have we wasted in excess of £50 million on failed projects and loans in the last decade or so?

In the hopes of uncovering a gem every couple of seasons or so?

As I alluded to earlier, why do we not reinvest the large sums we make on those gems wisely?

Richard Sellers/Allstar/Getty Images Sport

I’ll put it this way, if we sell Matt O’Riley for in excess of £30 million, do you imagine all of that money will be reinvested in the playing squad?

You know for a fact it won’t.

Because it never has been when we’ve sold players for large sums over the years.

Why should it change now?

We have spent £1 million in this transfer window so far.

As things stand, after the sales of Haksabanovic and Oh, we are actually in profit to the tune of around £3 million.

If Paolo Bernardo is unveiled before the end of the week, with his transfer fee believed to be around £3.5 million, our net spend will then be £500k.

Then, if we mange to secure Adam Idah for around the reported £6 million Norwich want for him, our net spend in this window thus far will be £6.5 million.

And let’s be straight on that, Norwich boss Johannes Hoff Thorup didn’t exactly fill me with hope on that score, in his post match interview after playing Club Brugge in Belgium.

Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images Sport

£6.5 million to stand still.

As we will be no better off than we were at the close of last season.

Theoretically, let’s then just say we sell Matt O’Riley and get £30 million for him.

Outside of the already burgeoning bank balance, we have that £30 million.

Most importantly, this will radically weaken our midfield.

I ask you again, do you think we’ll spend it all on player acquisitions?

Or on a like for like player similar to O’Riley?

Which would not come cheap.

You know we won’t.

To all of those board apologists out there who think I want our club to spend £50 million, a reasonable expectation for me would be to spend between £5 and £6 million on three to four first team ready players.

Add to that then, maybe two young projects for around the £2 million mark, and that to me would constitute good business.

That would constitute a good transfer window to me.

I don’t think that’s an unreasonable expectation, but do I think our board sees it that way?

Put simply, no I don’t.

Could I conceivably see us having just replaced the players that left our squad, and doing no more than that?

It wouldn’t shock me.

Like I said, spending enough to stand still.

Finally, why does our board always find the necessity to spend less that they receive on player transfers?

Would it kill us to actually reinvest what we make out of player sales in the playing squad?

It might actually give us a fighting chance in the Champions League group stages, don’t you think?

But hey, Peter Lawwell has already resigned himself to the fact we can’t compete at that level.

Mark Scates - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

So I guess that answers that.

Yes, there is movement this week in the transfer window.

But is it movement that will constitute any more than standing still?

Past experiences do not exactly fill me with hope.

I guess we’ll see who was right and who was wrong on August 30th, won’t we?

The form book tells me it’ll be me.

But I’ll happily be contradicted.

Wishful thinking….

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.