Skip to content

As Celtic casts a dark shadow over Ibrox, Heart and Hand podcaster David Edgar faces the reality of their hopeless position…

Share

As Celtic casts a dark shadow over Ibrox, Heart and Hand podcaster David Edgar faces the reality of their hopeless position…

Sometimes, although not often, I listen to Ibrox podcaster David Edgar’s Heart and Hand podcast.

I have listened to it on the occasions where Edgar has been full of bluster before they play us in a big game, to hear his reaction after they’ve lost.

Edgar is a strange character.

A man who seems to be intelligent enough, but at times has outbursts which contradict that intelligence.

I suppose a particular incident that stands out to me was his outburst before the 2023 League Cup final.

The “we are going to F*** you” outburst.

I’ll admit I never listened to anything by Edgar before that, but after we had beaten them 2-1 in that League Cup final, I tuned into his podcast to hear his reaction afterward.

Simply because his pre-match statement had gone viral.

I wanted to hear this nutjob, and his reaction to their loss.

I was surprised to hear a fairly balanced and intelligent podcast, and fairly balanced opinions from Edgar himself.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

After that, I tuned into the podcast a few more times, as we went on to win the treble that season.

It always seemed to be as I alluded to before, balanced and intelligent.

It’s been a while since I’ve listened to one of his podcasts, but I was recently sent a blog post by him from Joe McHugh.

I read it with interest.

It isn’t what you’d expect from somebody of an Ibrox persuasion.

There’s no hubris, no bluster, no bravado.

In fact, it’s quite the opposite.

There is almost an air of resignation about this article, resignation that this Ibrox side is not the old club.

That it does not have the ability to spend like the old club did.

An almost tacit acceptance that the club now has to live within it’s means.

But on top of that, Edgar does not have a good feeling about what’s coming down the line.

Ross MacDonald - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

This is some of what he had to say in his opening paragraph:

The beckoning summer offers a chance to rebuild, to replenish lost energies and gear up for the next season’s battles. This year, though, something feels different – and not in a good way.

And not in a good way.

As a Celtic supporter, I cannot feel any empathy for Edgar.

I understand how he feels, but in a cruel sort of way, I revel in it.

Sometimes I ask myself if that’s right, I ask myself if I should really revel in the pain of a fellow football supporter?

Edgar alludes to the 90’s later in his article, so do I think he reveled in my pain back then?

Of course he did.

He loved every second of it.

It’s why Ibrox supporters of his generation cling so desperately to it.

It’s why his podcast did a series called “Dominant” on that period.

But the overriding theme of this article seems to be that Edgar’s club is just incapable of getting anything right.

It is telling how he speaks about their support being “relieved” after each season ends.

And then it is refreshing when Edgar uses the word malaise to describe the position his club now finds itself in.

There is a malaise at Ibrox.

There has been since 2012, it’s just surprising that it’s taken Edgar until now to realise it.

That malaise is caused by living a lie.

By pretending to be something you are not.

By claiming that the old club bequeath it’s trophies to you, and that by doing so, you were somehow able to continue it’s history.

This malaise will never lift until such time as that club, and it’s supporters stop claiming to be something they’re not.

Visionhaus/Getty Images Sport

They have cursed themselves by claiming to be the same club.

In essence, the same club lie is a curse they just cannot shake.

To a degree, I believe there’s an awareness on Edgar’s part that this is the cause of the malaise.

But he cannot, and will not admit it to himself.

It’s kind of like an Elvis impersonator expecting everybody to believe he’s the real Elvis.

He looks like Elvis, talks like Elvis, sings like Elvis, but he isn’t Elvis.

Because Elvis is dead.

Sevco Scotland looks like Rangers 1872, acts like Rangers 1872, talks like Rangers 1872, but they aren’t Rangers 1872.

Because Rangers 1872 is dead.

Testimony to the fact they aren’t Rangers 1872, is their complete inability to emulate the old club’s achievements.

They just don’t win trophies like they used to.

Of course we know how the old club did that, and that it’s the reason they’re dead.

That club simply refused to live within it’s means.

SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

But it doesn’t change the fact that the current entity, since it came into existence, has only won three trophies of note.

David Edgar is a smart enough man to know this, and he says as much in his article:

FFP is another area which some of the support struggle with when they say the board ‘must back the manager’ when the fact is that even if a Shiekh came in tomorrow he wouldn’t be able to spend £100m on players without breaching UEFA rules. We have to live within our means and, for those of us who grew up in the 90s, that is incredibly frustrating.

Of course it’s incredibly frustrating!

Because he knows if the old club had lived within it’s means, farcical numbers such as 55 wouldn’t have been bandied about with abandon like they have been recently.

If that club had lived within it’s means, Celtic would be out of sight now.

And by out of sight, I mean out of sight of what the old club achieved.

Fact.

The air of resignation I spoke about earlier is plain to see later in the article.

Alan Harvey - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Edgar admits openly the club is in a mess:

The question isn’t if R*****s are a bit of a mess in summer 2024. With no CEO, Head of Academy or even a place to play when the season begins, we demonstrably are. The question is how we intend to emerge from it. What are the plans? Where are we going? How are we going to get there?

There are no plans.

They don’t even know where they’re going yet, with the start of the season just 3 over three weeks away.

It’s this “not knowing feeling” that feeds into the current malaise, which feeds into the overall malaise.

Which has been following them since 2012.

But if there’s one thing I can sympathise with Edgar on, it’s the silence from his board.

I know exactly how that feels, to a lesser extent, but I know.

Our board won’t communicate with us about player transfers, and that is the sum total of our worries right now.

The kind of worries Edgar has about his club far outweigh the kind we have.

As much as we might dislike our board, they run the club like a well oiled machine.

It’s just a shame they couldn’t spare some of that oil for the footballing operation.

Craig Foy - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

Ironically, the reason they won’t do that is down to exactly what Edgar is talking about in his article.

They watch what goes on at Ibrox.

What goes on at Ibrox defines what they are willing to spend.

And it may be the very reason they’ve spent the square root of f*** all in this transfer window so far.

However, Edgar’s admission that his club needs to live within it’s means could, whether we like it or not, be a dangerous thing.

An Ibrox club lacking hubris, showing humility, and living within it’s means, is far more of a threat to us than the rabid dog we’re used to dealing with.

Simply because our board would downsize to match and ensure the level of competitiveness between both clubs was entertaining.

After all, administering hidings on a regular basis to a side who has given up trying to keep up with us would eventually become boring, wouldn’t it?

Our board has always been of the opinion that we must have a competitive Ibrox side.

Ross Parker - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

It’s clear the lengths they will go to to ensure that.

In reality, if the Ibrox side downsizes, then so will we.

That would then mean constant humiliation in Europe.

Back to the old qualification routes, and a continuous decline in the European coefficient rankings.

The bigger question here though is this, how detrimental is the Ibrox stadium closure actually going to be to their club?

We have no idea as yet.

But the likes of David Edgar, a man who is close to the pulse of that club, is worried about the future.

Our club now casts a dark shadow over them.

We, alone, are worth more than the entire Scottish Premiership put together.

We, alone, can dictate whether we want to be competitive with them, or whether we want to pull away into the distance.

I don’t expect the latter to happen, simply because it never has.

And as long as we have the same grey men in the boardroom, who completely lack the ambition of the fanbase, it will never happen.

Lawwell et al have always been in thrall to the blue pound.

Craig Williamson - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images

And you can be sure they’re pretty restless watching events unfold as they are at Ibrox.

In fact, this very paragraph from David Edgar will be the cause of many sleepless nights for the likes of Lawwell:

R*****s are not, as I write this, at the point of crisis, but anyone who says they can’t see it hovering on the horizon is deluding themselves. This next month will, for good or worse, shape the whole tone of 24/25. R*****s still have the opportunity to take this moment, shape it and drive us on. Too often it feels like R*****s are a club where things happen to us, rather than because of us.

Crisis is hovering on the horizon.

To us Celtic fans, it is the stuff of dreams.

But to Lawwell and his cronies, the stuff of nightmares.

They do not have the vision to see beyond the Glasgow duopoly.

It’s highly unlikely they ever will.

As long as they are in situ, that will not change.

Soon enough, they might not have an Ibrox club to compete against.

Despite all of their efforts to keep things “competitive”.

When the whole existence of a club is built on lies, it will always exist in a state of malaise.

The same as a marriage that is built on lies, where spouses are unfaithful to each other, it will never survive.

A malaise ends when something either dies, or gets better.

Can you see the Ibrox club getting better?

I didn’t think so…

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.