Before I actually delve into the subject matter in the headline of my article, I need to clarify something.
Or more to the point, find an answer to the below question.
What is the exact definition of a “conspiracy theorist”?
According to the Oxford dictionary, a conspiracy theorist is a person who believes that some secret but influential organisation is responsible for a particular event or phenomenon.
So firstly, there’s your answer to that question, from the most respected dictionary in the English language.
It’s pretty clear.
The key words in that definition are “secret but influential organisation”.
Now secondly, the SFA is an “influential organisation”.
It influences everything in Scottish football.
Thirdly, and most importantly, it is not a secret organisation.
In order to be a secretive organisation, you need to be smart, cunning, clever, and devious.
The SFA is devious, but it is not cunning, smart, or clever.
If it was any of those three words, we might actually have a decent refereeing structure in Scotland.
But we don’t.
Instead we have a devious organisation, which is actually blatant in it’s favouritism towards one club, and equally blatant in it’s clear, open, and obvious dislike for Celtic.

In reality, there is no conspiracy at play here.
There is nothing whatsoever that is secretive about the SFA’s behaviour.
They do not even attempt to hide it.
Just look at the fact John Beaton is about to referee his sixth game involving Celtic, especially when you consider our club’s reservations when it comes to this referee.
So, in my view, to label Celtic fans as conspiracy theorists is just lazy journalism.
It is a cop out.
Used with unerring regularity by the likes of Keith Jackson, Stephen McGowan, and Hugh Keevins.
Simply because they want to ignore the real elephant in the room.
The fact that the Celtic fans might actually be right about the SFA and Scottish referees.
But the opinions of fans, like me, and every other blogger out there, don’t matter.
For most journalists worth their salt, the whole refereeing debate in Scotland would be one big juicy story.
As readership of the main titles in Scotland continues to decline, for reasons unknown to most sane people, the SMSM continues to ignore the blatant realities of the game in Fair Caledonia.
Of which there are many.
But none more obvious than the open bias on display in Scottish refereeing.
In an article in the Scottish Daily Mail, which Joe McHugh over at Videocelts highlighted yesterday, Stephen McGowan once again chose to skirt the real issues when it comes to Scottish refereeing.
In fact, he instead chose to defend the fact that Scottish referees do not have to declare their allegiances.
By ridiculing the fact that English referees do have to.
This was the opening headline in his article:
COMMENT: Asking Scottish referees to disclose their allegiances won’t remove suspicion… it just paints a target on their backs

So, by definition, that must then mean that every referee in England has a target painted on their backs?
Or did he just mean that the majority of Scottish referees would have a target painted on their backs?
Because they support one club?
In other the words, the conspiracy theorists would have licence to voice their conspiracy theories openly, once it was obvious the majority of referees supported the Ibrox club.
What he really means is that Celtic fans would be the ones aiming at the targets painted on the referee’s backs.
Now, I’m not going to go into the details of McGowan’s article.
Joe McHugh has that well covered, and you can click the link provided earlier to see his dissection of the article in question.
I will only refer to certain aspects of it which are relevant to this article.
In Tuesday’s article, I discussed the fact that no Scottish referees will be at Euro 2024.
In it, I spoke about the fact that two small national leagues in Slovakia and Slovenia, were able to produce well respected professional referees.
Yet, in a league that has average attendances which are 8 times larger than in those leagues, the SFA persists with amateur referees.

The majority of whose allegiances are well known to all of us conspiracy theorists.
Yesterday, Stephen McGowan was at pains to defend that refereeing structure.
This particular segment of McGowan’s article really stood out to me:
Making referees declare the team they grew up supporting is not a recipe for honesty, transparency and fairness. It’s pandering to people who see conspiracy in the cornflakes when the milk turns.
Fans of Celtic and R*****s think they know which team John Beaton, Willie Collum, David Dickinson and Kevin Clancy support.
Whether they do or they don’t is neither here nor there. They think they do and that’s good enough for some to demand the exclusion of a referee from games involving their team in future. Or, if Forest have their way, any game involving a team which raises any hint of a conflict of interest of any kind. Just because they are incapable of looking at any decision objectively, they assume everyone else is the same.
McGowan felt it was necessary to dissect the English refereeing system after Nottingham Forest claimed Stuart Atwell had an affiliation with Luton Town.
Forest were aggrieved because Atwell, as VAR, denied them three penalty reviews, when they felt the incidents in question should at least have been looked at.
Their argument was that Atwell, who they stated was a Luton Town fan, should not have been VAR for a tie that he could influence in favour of their direct relegation rivals.
So, to you and me, the conspiracy theorists, that is in direct contravention of the rules the FA have in place when it comes to referee allegiances in English football.
To Stephen Mcgowan, Nottingham Forest are seeping desperation and entitlement from every pore.
Kind of like us Celtic fans, you know?
I’m afraid Mcgowan’s theory does not stand up.
The FA have these rules in place for a reason, they are to eliminate the possibility of bias.
They are to ensure referees cannot influence games to benefit their favourite sides.
Directly or indirectly.
And it works, most of the time.
Just not this time.
In my view, Nottingham Forest have every right to feel aggrieved.
They believe the rules have not been adhered to, and they are questioning it.
Which is their right.
Effectively, Stephen McGowan is saying that by making referees in England declare their allegiances, this is pandering to conspiracy theorists.
But by not making referees declare allegiances in Scotland, you are not pandering to conspiracy theorists?
Go figure.
Confused yet?
Once again, there is no conspiracy in Scotland.
John Beaton supports the Ibrox club, he drinks in a well know Ibrox bar.
He has a fan club at Ibrox dedicated to him.

This is not a conspiracy.
Neither is it a conspiracy that the Ibrox side stated vehemently they did not want Willie Collum refereeing games involving their club.
Because of his allegiances.
Nor is it a conspiracy that he has not refereed a single league game involving the Ibrox side since December of last year.
It isn’t a conspiracy that Celtic politely asked for the same thing when it came to John Beaton, and they’ve pretty much been told where to go.

Evidenced by the fact he is refereeing our game against Dundee at the weekend, directly after he also refereed his previous game involving us at Ibrox.
No conspiracies at play whatsoever here.
Just blatant, obvious, in your f£$%ing face facts.
McGowan then goes on to say it’s all fine and dandy in England, because they have a pool of 50 million people to choose from for their referees.
But that Scotland has population a tenth of that figure.
It still doesn’t stand up:
Disqualifying officials with a suspected or stated affiliation to Celtic or Rangers wouldn’t just stop them handling Glasgow derbies. In a nip-and-tuck race for the title, they wouldn’t be trusted with any game likely to impact the final outcome. Competent, qualified category-one officials would spend weeks on the sofa watching inferior referees handle the top fixtures by default because they grew up as an atheist in Forfar or Formartine.
Why doesn’t his argument stand up?
Well I’ll refer back to my article on Tuesday.
Where I discussed the referees from Slovenia and Slovakia.
Slovenia has a population of just over 2 million people, about 3.5 million less than Scotland.
Yet this country can manage to provide professional referees for it’s top league.
Slovakia has the same populace as Scotland, yet this country can provide professional referees for it’s top league.
These countries can manage to provide referees who get to referee European finals, and big European club games.
These countries can provide referees who regularly get to officiate at major international tournaments.
They are not hampered by the size of their populations.
Both countries have derby rivalries like Scotland, albeit on a smaller scale.
How can they do that?
More to the point, why can’t Scotland do that?
Why can’t the SFA reform refereeing in Scotland by making referees professional?

What is stopping them from doing that?
Stephen McGowan is at pains to point out that allegiances mean nothing, and that there are no conspiracy theories at play in the Scottish game.
So I guess that just leaves one other issue, doesn’t it?
Incompetence.
Something Scottish referees are constantly accused of.
Because they are amateurs.
We daren’t speak of bias, or unconscious bias in Scotland, but we can just about mention incompetence.
Make referees professionals, and then you can go a long way to eliminating incompetence.
Will it eliminate bias?
It’s unlikely, but it would be a start.
It might just pave the way for true reform when it comes to refereeing in the Scottish game.
And that, above all else, is what’s needed now.
Click here for – NO SCOTTISH REFEREES AT EURO 2024 TELLS IT’S OWN STORY, WHILE BEATON REFEREES YET ANOTHER MATCH INVOLVING CELTIC
Click here for – “WHY DON’T THEY JUST PLAY EACH OTHER EVERY WEEK? FORGET THE REST!” JEFF STELLING RIDICULES THE AMOUNT OF TIMES CELTIC AND THE IBROX SIDE FACE OFF AGAINST EACH OTHER














Comments.
Loading comments…