Skip to content

Too many “exclusives”, and no real story. How to tell the difference between a real Celtic blogger and clickbait merchants

Share

Too many “exclusives”, and no real story. How to tell the difference between a real Celtic blogger and clickbait merchants

As Celtic bloggers, we often write about how there is a dearth of quality stories out there when it comes journalism in Scotland.

In a country where there is so much newsworthy content to write about, the media chooses to ignore the juicy stuff, and instead they just paste and copy.

Scotland’s current crop of journalists are nothing more than stenographers.

They transcribe stories they find elsewhere, some of them even transcribe stories they find on clickbait websites.

Stories which claim to be “exclusives”, but are actually nothing more than clickbait, designed to draw you in, and leave you no more wiser when you finish, than when you began.

Original thought is becoming a rare commodity.

Putting time and effort into a story is secondary to “racking up the clicks” now.

And yes, while clicks are incentivised through monetary reward, there are a few of us still left who believe that the people who read our stories should actually get a story that is worth reading.

An honest day’s pay for an honest day’s work and all that…

As bloggers go, I would be considered a greenhorn, simply because I’ve only been blogging for 3 years now.

That’s not to say I’m new to writing, I’m not.

I’ve dabbled for many years.

There are a select few out there who are real veterans.

Bloggers who have been at this for much longer than I have.

They are easily identifiable, before I started blogging, they were my go to sites.

They still are.

I have Joe McHugh of Videocelts to thank for getting me a gig with Read Celtic.

Joe has been a blogger for many years now, and always has his finger on the pulse.

Without his help and guidance, I wouldn’t be where I am today.

I would not consider myself part of the elite in terms of Celtic blogging.

In fact, I feel I have quite a way to go yet before I hit that status.

But I do believe in original thought.

I believe every day when I write a story about Celtic, that it should allow the reader to become immersed in it.

And by the end of it, the reader should feel satisfied that he/she has read something worth reading.

Something worth their time.

Sadly, the elite in Celtic blogging, are becoming a minority.

Surrounded by clickbait sites, with headlines that draw you into a website believing you’re about to read an “exclusive”, a story that will tell you something nobody else knows.

One site in particular is so cute, or devious, whichever way you want to look at it, that they will not mention the player or person they’re referring to involved in Celtic until at least the 3rd or 4th paragraph of their article.

So, sometimes you spend half the article not having a clue who it is they’re actually writing about.

By the time you’ve actually read the story, you realise it’s either completely bogus, or it reveals nothing at all related to the headline that drew you in the first place.

But hey, the author got their click, so for them, it’s mission accomplished.

For them, it isn’t about the writing, it’s about what they can make out of you.

I believe a lot of these clickbait merchants are now also using chat GBT to write their Celtic articles.

At times, there’s an almost robotic feel to what you’re reading.

And let’s be straight here, if they can speed up the process to achieving a click, then they’ll do that, won’t they?

Recently, Joe McHugh alerted me to the fact that a site was plagiarising my work.

When I looked at what he sent me, it was 100% a clickbait site.

It was drowning in ads, but they had literally pasted and copied my article into it, and then edited it, I believe, using chat GBT.

I asked Google if chat GBT can plagiarise, and below is the answer I got:

ChatGPT does not plagiarize in the traditional sense of copying and pasting the work of others. It is trained on a massive dataset of text and code, and it uses this knowledge to generate new text that is similar to the text it has been trained on.

Which pretty much means it can.

New text that is similar to the text it has been trained on.

Enough said.

I guess what I’m saying is that most of you readers out there are smart enough to identify who is writing an original piece and who is not.

But at the same time, I’m trying to show you how you can avoid being duped into reading clickbait which tells you the square root of f*** all new.

These last few days, the clickbait merchants have gone into overdrive.

But there is one site in particular, which boast “exclusives” and supposedly seeks the knowledge of “experts” for all of it’s articles.

Football Insider.

Boasting “experts” like Frank McAvvennie, Alan Hutton, and Keith “who is he???” Wyness.

And of course, lest we forget, finance expert, Kieran Maguire.

Their exclusives are about as exclusive as owning a Toyota Yaris, and their experts talk through their backsides.

But here’s the thing.

Our stenographers actually think this website is so good, that even they regurgitate their stories.

Now, obviously it’s a bonus if there’s an anti-Celtic slant in the stories.

That’s what makes this site a must for the likes of the Daily Record and The Sun.

Isn’t it sad that this is what journalism is now reduced to?

Yesterday, there was an “exclusive” on the demands Brendan Rodgers was going to place on the board for transfers next season.

Apparently they only figured out he was “furious” now, and not last August.

Back when we were buying £2 to £3 million projects, hand over fist.

Then, to make matters worse, another clickbait site decided to regurgitate this story, using a similar headline.

I’m not going to name the site, because I’m not in the habit of calling out other sites for poor content, they know who they are.

More to the point, I’m sure you do too.

But there’s one thing I can guarantee you, the majority of these clickbait sites are not invested in Celtic like the real bloggers are.

They are not real fans, like us.

They don’t care about Celtic, they only care about what they can make out of Celtic.

I have supported Celtic for 4 decades.

I have a huge historic knowledge of the club, both through my own experiences, and my thirst for knowledge about the club.

My Grandfather introduced me to Celtic.

I make no bones when I say I am a real Celtic supporter, passionate and invested.

I’ve lived through the darkest of days at our club.

I’ve seen it all, been through it all, and I’d like to think that’s reflected in what I write about the club.

I write about Celtic, because I care about Celtic.

So, what’s the moral of this story?

When you see a headline with “exclusive” in it, it is never an “exclusive”.

When you see a player referred to as “player” in a headline, with no name given, you are being drawn into a story that will tell you nothing.

And it’ll be quite a while before you find out who that “player” is.

By which time, you will have lost the will to live.

Educate yourself on who the real bloggers are, the ones who will tell you a real story.

We might not have “exclusives”, in fact, we rarely claim that we do.

But what we will do is take a fake story apart, take apart journalists who unjustly criticise our club, and call out the bullshit we see week in, and week out in our game.

We will call out our board when they fail to look after our club the way they’re paid to.

And we will call out our board when they neglect to look after the core of our operation, the playing squad.

We don’t pretend to know everything, or to have inside stories.

But what we do have is a deep and extensive knowledge of the club we write about.

We understand, and we can predict, with accuracy, a lot of what will happen in our game, and at our club.

That comes from years of following Celtic, and understanding the Scottish game.

And finally, what we will never do, is plagiarise, or past and copy other people’s work.

It’s not about the clicks for us, it’s about the story.

Getting our story out there to tell our fanbase what’s really going on.

It’s about calling out the SMSM when they spout bullshit about our club.

We do this because we care.

Because we love Celtic.

That’s it really.

Click here for – TAVERNIER’S BLUNDER AGAINST CELTIC ON SUNDAY BLOWS APART THE MYTH HE IS SOME KIND OF WORLD CLASS DEFENDER, AND SOUTHGATE SAW IT TOO

Click here for – AS CELTIC QUESTION THE SFA ABOUT THAT PENALTY INCIDENT, WE ALL KNOW THEY’LL GET NO MEANINGFUL RESPONSE

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.