Skip to content

Penrice Gets Away With Embarrassing Dive — VAR and Scottish Refereeing Under the Spotlight Again

Share

Scottish referee blowing whistle and saying Penalty rangers in a speech bubble with all rangers players diving around the pit

Scottish football has produced another refereeing controversy, and this time James Penrice is at the centre of it… unsurprisingly a penalty for Ra***rs

The Ra***rs defender “won” a penalty against St Mirren after going to ground in an incident that will leave plenty of Celtic supporters questioning how the decision was reached.

Let’s be honest, it was an embarrassing attempt to win a penalty. Yet somehow, it was enough to convince the officials… unsurprisingly.

The bigger issue is that VAR was there to review the incident, and the penalty still stood.

What exactly are we using VAR for if incidents like this are not being properly scrutinised?

We see marginal offsides reviewed down to the millimetre, yet when it comes to potential simulation, the standard of intervention seems completely different.

Players know that going to ground can win them a decision. If there is no consequence for obvious simulation, why would that behaviour stop?

Scottish refereeing has been under scrutiny for years, and incidents like this do absolutely nothing to improve confidence in the officials.

Penrice got his penalty, Ran***s got their advantage, and we are all left asking the same question once again.

Is VAR actually improving Scottish football refereeing, or simply giving us another reason to argue about it?

Key Takeaways

  • James Penrice won a controversial penalty for Hearts against St Mirren, raising questions about the decision-making process.
  • Despite the presence of VAR, the penalty decision remained after a questionable simulation attempt.
  • The inconsistency in VAR intervention for potential simulation compared to marginal offsides is seriously concerning.
  • Obvious simulation could lead to a culture where players go to ground without fear of consequences, affecting the integrity of the game.
  • Scottish refereeing continues to face scrutiny, with incidents like this damaging confidence in officials.

Jump to comments

Aodhán Ó Conchobhair started writing in 2025. A lifelong Celtic supporter, now living in London after graduating from Strathclyde University in 2024. Before getting into writing, Aidan worked as a talent ID academy scout with Hibernian, where he managed their London network, covering age groups from U15 through to U21 level. That role had him regularly watching youth football, tracking development, and helping identify players who could make the step up into professional environments. It gave him a strong grounding in how clubs actually operate behind the scenes when it comes to recruitment and academy pathways. In 2025, he moved into writing and quickly began contributing to Celtic-focused fan media. His articles have featured in both The Celtic Way and The Celtic Cynic, where he’s built a reputation for informed analytical pieces.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.