Skip to content

Why Would Kieran McKenna Come to Celtic? We Have Become a Poisoned Chalice

Share

Kieran McKenna in a Celtic tracksuit

Kieran McKenna is exactly the sort of manager Celtic should be looking at. Young, ambitious, tactically progressive and with a track record of building a team capable of achieving more than people expected.

But there is one question I cannot get out of my head: why would he choose Celtic when his career could take him towards the biggest jobs in English football?

McKenna transformed Ipswich Town, guiding them from League One to the Premier League through three promotions. His reputation grew to the point where he was linked with Manchester United, Chelsea and Brighton. He eventually stepped away from Ipswich in June 2026 to take a break from management, rather than immediately jumping into another job.

Now, with Celtic reportedly among his admirers, the opportunity to manage us could be tempting. We are a massive club, we can offer European football, passionate supporters and the chance to compete for trophies. But we need to be honest about the other side of the argument.

Have Celtic become a poisoned chalice?

Look at the treatment of our recent managers. Ange Postecoglou delivered domestic success and took us into the Champions League, yet eventually left for Tottenham. Brendan Rodgers returned, won trophies and then saw his relationship with the board deteriorate amid public disagreements over recruitment and the direction of the club. The fallout became so toxic that even the wider debate around Celtic turned into a battle over who was to blame.

Why would McKenna willingly walk into that environment?

He has already demonstrated that he can build something special at Ipswich. He has spoken about wanting attacking football, player development and a meaningful connection with a club and its community. Those are qualities we should be desperate to encourage.

But those ambitions require more than a manager with a good reputation. They require a board prepared to back him, recruit players who fit his system and give him the authority to build a team.

And that is where my concern lies.

If Manchester United came calling in the future, the appeal would be obvious. McKenna knows the club from his time coaching there, and managing one of the biggest clubs in world football would represent a huge opportunity. There is no guarantee he will get that job, but why would he rule out that level of ambition by taking on a Celtic project that could become a political battleground?

The reported £8 million compensation owed to Ipswich for his appointment is another obstacle, particularly if our board is unwilling to make a serious financial statement.

I would love McKenna at Celtic. I think he could bring fresh ideas, develop our younger players and give us a long-term footballing identity.

But we cannot simply expect a highly rated manager to arrive, fix everything and accept responsibility when the club’s wider structure lets him down.

Celtic should be a stepping stone to greatness, not a job managers think twice about accepting.

If we want McKenna, the board must sell him a vision, not just the size of the club and the expectation of winning trophies.

Because right now, the biggest question is not whether Kieran McKenna is good enough for Celtic.

It is whether Celtic are prepared to be good enough for Kieran McKenna.

Key Takeaways

  • Kieran McKenna is a strong managerial candidate for Celtic, known for his success at Ipswich Town, but his interest remains uncertain.
  • Celtic’s recent managerial turmoil raises concerns about why McKenna would choose this role amidst potential opportunities in English football.
  • To succeed, McKenna would need backing from the club’s board and a commitment to building a cohesive team.
  • The financial compensation owed for McKenna’s appointment could also deter Celtic from pursuing him seriously.
  • Celtic must offer more than just history; they need to present a clear vision to attract a top manager like McKenna.

Jump to comments

Aodhán Ó Conchobhair started writing in 2025. A lifelong Celtic supporter, now living in London after graduating from Strathclyde University in 2024. Before getting into writing, Aidan worked as a talent ID academy scout with Hibernian, where he managed their London network, covering age groups from U15 through to U21 level. That role had him regularly watching youth football, tracking development, and helping identify players who could make the step up into professional environments. It gave him a strong grounding in how clubs actually operate behind the scenes when it comes to recruitment and academy pathways. In 2025, he moved into writing and quickly began contributing to Celtic-focused fan media. His articles have featured in both The Celtic Way and The Celtic Cynic, where he’s built a reputation for informed analytical pieces.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.