Skip to content

Celtic denied, Rangers protected from a penalty: Collum exposes the failures

Share

Celtic denied, Rangers protected from a penalty: Collum exposes the failures

Celtic denied, Rangers spared. Willie Collum’s latest admissions leave Scottish football facing an uncomfortable contrast that supporters have every right to challenge.

The Scottish FA’s head of refereeing has acknowledged two penalty errors: one deprived Celtic of a spot-kick at Motherwell; another spared Rangers conceding one against St Mirren.

The same two officials were involved in both matches.

For me, that demands considerably more than another explanation after the damage is done.

Celtic penalty denied despite VAR

At Fir Park on 11 October, Callum McGregor’s shot struck Lukas Fadinger’s arm. Celtic received a corner.

Steven McLean refereed, with Don Robertson on VAR. Neither delivered the penalty Collum now accepts should have been awarded.

Celtic won 2–0, but that cannot excuse the failure. Winning does not cancel our entitlement to correct decisions.

Why should supporters accept technology that records an incident clearly enough for a later admission, yet fails to produce the right outcome during the match?

Rangers benefited when the roles were reversed

Against St Mirren at Ibrox, Robertson refereed while McLean operated VAR.

Emmanuel Fernandez caught Ismeal Kabia inside the box with the match goalless. St Mirren received nothing; Rangers eventually won 1–0.

Collum’s assessment was unequivocal: “a penalty kick, without question”.

Same officials. Different roles. Two failures, with Celtic disadvantaged and Rangers benefiting.

That contrast fuels suspicions of unequal treatment. Collum must answer those concerns through demonstrably consistent officiating and meaningful accountability.

Another handball dispute that same weekend

Kevin Kelsy’s goal against Kilmarnock on 10 October also prompted a handball complaint from Neil McCann.

Bobby Madden defended the decision, arguing that the footage did not clearly establish arm contact. That incident remains disputed.

The following day, however, Celtic were denied a penalty that Collum now acknowledges.

Supporters deserve transparent explanations of the evidence required for VAR intervention.

Celtic supporters remember earlier failures

McLean officiated the 2015 Inverness semi-final, when Josh Meekings’ hand stopped Leigh Griffiths’ header without a penalty.

Robertson awarded Ross County’s 2017 penalty after Alex Schalk went down without contact.

Those failures predated VAR. Technology has arrived; the frustration remains.

We demand accountability from Celtic’s leadership and coaching staff. Officials deserve equally searching scrutiny.

Collum must explain what changes when established referees keep getting major decisions wrong. Celtic deserve fairness during matches, not vindication weeks afterwards.

Jump to comments

Phil Cooney I'm 52 years old and from Coatbridge, and Celtic has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Supporting the club isn't just a hobby for me – it's part of who I am. My first visit to Celtic Park came in 1985 against St Mirren, and from that day I was hooked. Like so many supporters of my generation, I grew up idolising Paul McStay. His loyalty, class and ability made him my favourite player, and he remains the player who best represents what Celtic means to me. The Centenary Season will always hold a special place in my heart. Watching Billy McNeill lead the club to that unforgettable league title is a memory I'll never forget, and it's still the benchmark for what Celtic should strive to be. Through this site I write as a supporter first and foremost. I'll praise the club when praise is deserved, but I won't shy away from questioning decisions or expressing concerns when I believe standards have slipped. My aim is to offer honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and passionate discussion on everything happening at Celtic. Whether it's transfer news, match analysis, or the bigger issues surrounding the club, I write from the perspective of someone who has lived and breathed Celtic for over four decades. Hail Hail.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.