Skip to content

Today can be the beginning or the end at Celtic for Martin O’Neill, all he has to do is get his team selection right

Share

Today can be the beginning or the end at Celtic for Martin O’Neill, all he has to do is get his team selection right

Today’s game at home at Celtic Park against Hearts is very important for Martin O’Neill for a few different reasons.

Credibility is the first of these reasons, and I’ll tell you why.

When the final whistle blew after the Scottish Cup final, Martin O’Neill had infinite credit in the bank with the Celtic support.

Hell, he even had infinite credit with the SMSM.

He had just completed a double in miraculous circumstances.

All the plaudits coming his way were more than deserved.

Nobody would have argued if a statue was erected in his honour at Celtic Park, such was the euphoria surrounding what he’d just achieved

When you have that kind of credit in the bank, it’s the right time to call time on things and lap up the plaudits.

I’m not going to go into the story of why Martin O’Neill returned for another year.

Nor am I going to go into the reasons why.

We all know why.

He was the second choice candidate, and when the first choice candidate was no longer a viable option, Dermot Desmond picked up the phone to Martin O’Neill.

If Martin had any self esteem, regardless of the finances on offer, he would have told Dermot Desmond where to go.

“I’m nobody’s second choice!” should have been his answer.

He would have been well within his rights to react that way considering what he had done for the club in delivering an unlikely double.

But he has accepted being second choice, and now it looks as if that acceptance might be his downfall

So I’ll go back to credibility.

No matter how limitless it may have been when this season commenced, with each passing media conference, farcical result, and inexplicable team selection over the course of this campaign, it has started to wane.

Rapidly.

It drained significantly last Thursday night.

Firstly, O’Neill’s team selection for the game against Benfica left many people scratching their heads.

Secondly, his reaction to the 4-1 defeat then had fans thinking they were being taken for mugs.

There was nothing positive to be taken from that result.

Nothing.

That might sound harsh.

But if Martin O’Neill was determined to set us up to fail, then he cannot possibly be taken seriously when he says the second half performance was “terrific”

The word terrific is rooted in the Latin word terrificus (“causing fear”), though this literal sense is rarely used today.

I’d be quite happy to use it in that literal sense when it comes to Martin O’Neill right now.

He causes me a lot of fear with each passing game.

Which brings me to today’s game at Celtic Park.

Last night, Martin O’Neill was presented with a gift horse by the very man that tore his side asunder at Ibrox last month, Dan Neil.

Neil was caught napping deep in his own half by Callum Jones, who dispossessed him easily in front of his own box.

Jones duly took the gift presented to him, and slotted it into the bottom right corner of Ivor Pandur’s goal.

As a result, Celtic have the chance to go 4 points clear today

But we must also bear in mind that Hearts have the chance to close the gap on us to 2 points, and to 1 point on the Ibrox side.

So there is plenty of incentive for both sides this afternoon.

In my headline, I said today could be the beginning or the end for Martin O’Neill.

What I meant by that is that it could be the beginning of a serious run for us, or it could be the end because if we lose today, Martin has to be teetering on the edge if that happens.

Not many Celtic managers survive 5 defeats out of 6.

We are approaching Wilfried Nancy territory here.

If we, as many people suspect we will, lose to Celta Vigo on Thursday night, that could be 6 out of 7 losses.

This will match Wilfried Nancy’s loss record.

One wonders if Silent Mike will develop the same testicular fortitude in this situation as he did when it came to sacking Nancy if that happens?

However, there is a very easy solution to all of this for Martin O’Neill.

The only problem is that this solution for the manager also involves testicular fortitude to be forthcoming from him.

Drop the players who are not performing.

Get the team selection right.

Drop Viljami Sinisalo, he has conceded 11 goals in his last 4 starts.

Rest Callum McGregor.

Do NOT start Sebastian Tounekti.

Play Camilo Duran through the middle.

Start Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain in midfield.

Drop Kasper Hogh, regardless of his price tag.

If you have to play the front three that were “terrific” on Thursday night, then just f***ing do it!

Finally, do NOT have Dane Murray next or near the starting line up.

Here is the starting line up I would pick:

Johnson, Tierney, Scales, Trusty, Donovan, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Baur, Nygren, Osmand, Duran, Hassan.

That, I think, is as effective a starting eleven as O’Neill could pick today after Thursday night’s shit show.

If he persists with the players who have been underperforming, and I include Callum McGregor in that category, then we are asking for trouble.

He is asking for trouble.

If he cannot see that for himself at this point, then I have no sympathy for him.

Derek McInnes has handed us a golden opportunity going into today’s game.

It would be idiocy on Martin O’Neill’s part not to take full advantage of that

Make the right team selection.

Win this game, and start a run where we can be taken seriously again.

It can either be the beginning or the end, it’s entirely the manager’s choice.

But if we lose today, and again on Thursday, it’s will be time to call time on this shitshow.

The credibility that was infinite at the start of this season, will be completely drained.

Be smart Martin.

Make the right team selection.

Key Takeaways

  • Today’s match at Celtic Park is crucial for Martin O’Neill’s credibility.
  • His previous successes earned him infinite credit, but poor recent performances are eroding that trust.
  • O’Neill must make significant team changes to secure a win; otherwise, he risks losing his job.
  • The team selection and performance against Benfica have left fans feeling frustrated and confused.
  • If O’Neill wants to stay, he needs to show courage and make the right decisions on player selections.

Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.