There is a strange attitude that has developed around the Celtic board room in recent years.
It is almost as if we are supposed to be incredibly thankful simply for being Celtic supporters.
Thankful for the trophies. Thankful for the “European” qualification. Thankful for the stadium. Thankful for the revenue. Thankful for the position the club finds itself in.
And whenever supporters dare to question what is happening, the response can sometimes feel like: What exactly are you complaining about? Look at what you have.
But that misses the entire point.
We know what we have. That’s precisely why we expect more.
We aren’t demanding that Celtic suddenly start competing for the Champions League.
We’re asking for a club with Celtic’s resources, support, history and potential to actually behave like it believes those things matter.
And there is a huge difference between being successful and being ambitious.
We don’t need to be told how lucky we are
Celtic win the league. Celtic qualify for Europe. Celtic generate enormous revenues. Celtic have tens of thousands of supporters turning up every week.
The board can point at all of that and say:
“Look at what we’ve achieved. What more do you want?”
The answer is simple.
We want Celtic to be better.
That’s not ingratitude.
That’s ambition.
The problem is that success domestically can create a strange mentality within a football club. When you win regularly, it becomes very easy to convince yourself that everything is working perfectly.
But supporters aren’t judging Celtic purely against Scottish football.
We’re looking at Europe.
We’re looking at the money coming into the club.
We’re looking at the opportunities that exist.
We’re looking at clubs with considerably smaller resources who seem to have clearer strategies, better recruitment or greater ambition.
And we’re asking why Celtic sometimes operate as though we should be grateful for scraps from a table we are perfectly capable of sitting at ourselves.
Desmond’s Tyranny
This is where the Dermot Desmond argument becomes particularly important.
There is a perception among some supporters that Desmond has done Celtic some enormous personal favour simply by being involved with the club.
And there are obviously things that can be acknowledged about his involvement and the role he has played.
But let’s not lose sight of what Celtic actually is.
Owning a significant stake in Celtic isn’t an act of charity.
Celtic generates enormous amounts of money.
Supporters spend enormous amounts of money.
Players and managers are employed to deliver success.
Directors are paid to run the organisation.
This is a football club.
It isn’t a benevolent institution where supporters should be standing outside the boardroom saying:
“Thank you, sir, for allowing us to watch Celtic.”
And yet there can sometimes be an attitude that because we have success, because we have trophies, we should simply shut up and accept whatever comes next.
No.
Supporters don’t owe the board unconditional gratitude.
The relationship should work both ways.
Respect isn’t a one-way street
This is what makes the recent confrontation between the club and sections of the support in St Andrews so uncomfortable.
Celtic has made its position clear. It expects supporters to behave responsibly and says the club’s reputation is non-negotiable.
But if supporters are expected to take responsibility for their actions, shouldn’t the same principle apply to those running Celtic?
If recruitment fails, who is accountable?
If the squad isn’t good enough, who is accountable?
If European campaigns repeatedly leave supporters asking whether the club is serious about competing, who is accountable?
If communication between the board and supporters breaks down, who is accountable?
You cannot demand accountability from supporters while treating accountability in the boardroom as an unreasonable request.
And you certainly cannot expect supporters to be grateful simply because the club is successful enough to keep winning Scottish trophies.
The most frustrating thing is that we’re not asking for the impossible
This is the bit I think the board completely misses.
We’re not asking for perfection.
We’re asking for competence, ambition and a genuine attempt to maximise what Celtic can be.
Recruit properly.
Plan ahead.
Replace important players properly.
Invest when the opportunity is there.
Build for Europe rather than simply hoping we stumble into the Champions League again.
Communicate honestly with supporters.
And when something goes wrong, don’t tell us to be grateful.
Tell us what you’re going to do about it.
The board might look at Celtic and see a hugely successful club.
But supporters are grateful for the players who have given everything for the shirt.
We’re grateful for the people who have kept this club alive through generations.
But gratitude shouldn’t become an excuse for complacency.
Being grateful for what Celtic has achieved doesn’t mean being satisfied with what the Celtic board is capable of achieving.
Those are two completely different things.
And if the board genuinely believes that supporters should be happy simply because Celtic are winning domestically, then perhaps the problem isn’t the supporters’ expectations.
Perhaps the problem is that the board’s expectations are too low.
Celtic belongs to the supporters too
This is ultimately what the argument comes down to.
The board has its responsibilities.
Dermot Desmond has his influence.
The executives have their jobs.
But Celtic is much bigger than any individual sitting in a boardroom.
It belongs to generations of supporters who have poured money, time and emotion into this club.
Those supporters aren’t customers who should be grateful for whatever product they’re handed.
They’re the reason Celtic exists in the first place.
So when supporters demand more, that shouldn’t automatically be interpreted as entitlement.
Sometimes it is simply love for the club combined with the belief that it can do better.
And perhaps that’s the part the board needs to understand.
We aren’t angry because we don’t appreciate Celtic.
We’re angry because we appreciate Celtic enough to believe it should be better.
We’re just asking the people running Celtic to stop telling us how lucky we are to have what we’ve got and start showing us how ambitious they are about what we could have.
Because Celtic supporters don’t need to be told to be grateful.
We need to be given something worth being proud of.
Key Takeaways
- Supporters feel the Celtic board assumes they should be grateful for success, but they want more ambition and competence from the club.
- Celtic’s resources and history demand a higher expectation for performance, especially in Europe.
- Desmond’s involvement in Celtic should not be seen as charity; he has a stake in a profitable football club.
- Supporters want accountability from the board as they take responsibility for their actions.
- Gratitude for past successes shouldn’t lead to complacency; supporters expect genuine ambition and improvement from Celtic.














Comments.
Loading comments…