Martin O’Neill warned us.
Only days ago, after watching Celtic labour to a 1-0 victory over St Johnstone, he admitted his side were “still well short”.
He even joked that, at 74 years old, he could have scored one of the chances Celtic squandered.
I wrote about his comments on this site and the fact I felt Martin seemed less than convinced of his side.
Well, after watching Celtic get dismantled 3-0 by Rangers at Ibrox today, it would be very easy to point back towards those comments and say the manager has been proven correct.
He has.
But that doesn’t mask what were, in my opinion, some disastrous decisions from O’Neill himself today.
Rangers didn’t sneak this. They didn’t require a refereeing controversy or a fortunate deflection.
They deservedly beat Celtic.
Dan Neil scored twice, Kevin Kelsy got the other and Rangers caused Celtic problems throughout, particularly through Djeidi Gassama. Celtic, meanwhile, offered nowhere near enough going forward.
That hurts to admit, but I’m not interested in dressing it up, it’s not my style.
O’Neill has spent the last week telling us this team needs to improve. He openly questioned whether Celtic could function without Camilo Duran after resting him against St Johnstone.
Again, he was right.
Yet today was also about what the manager did with the players available to him.
Celtic arrived at Ibrox with a perfect Premiership record. Six games, six victories and five points clear of Rangers.
Nobody expected perfection, but I certainly expected Celtic to look like Celtic.
Instead, Rangers dictated far too much of this game.
O’Neill’s setup didn’t work. Celtic struggled to establish control in midfield, Rangers found space to hurt us and our attacking threat was nowhere near what you’d expect from a team containing the quality Celtic possess.
When it became obvious things weren’t working, I wanted a decisive reaction.
It never really came.
Changes were made, but nothing fundamentally altered the direction of the match. Rangers remained comfortable and Celtic increasingly looked like a team hoping something might happen rather than one capable of making it happen.
That’s on the manager.
There can be two truths here.
O’Neill can be correct that this Celtic squad remains short of where he wants it to be.
Supporters can also believe he got today badly wrong.
He did get it wrong.
One shouldn’t be used to excuse the other.
I’ve criticised Celtic’s recruitment repeatedly. We went into the Champions League qualifiers without a finished squad, watched the LASK disaster unfold and then conducted a frantic amount of business at the end of the window.
Those decisions have consequences.
However, this isn’t LASK.
Celtic had their new players available today. O’Neill had decisions to make about how to use them, how to set his team up and how to respond when Rangers took control.
His decisions didn’t work.
Perhaps the most concerning thing is that today’s result didn’t arrive completely out of nowhere.
St Johnstone gave Celtic warning signs on Wednesday. O’Neill himself acknowledged them afterwards.
We won that game, so it was easy enough to move on.
You can’t move on quite so easily from this.
Three-nil at Ibrox.
Out of the League Cup.
Barely laying a glove on Rangers when the first domestic trophy of the season was on the line.
That’s unacceptable for Celtic.
But today the criticism has to travel in his direction too.
Martin warned us Celtic were well short.
Today proved his point.
Unfortunately for him, it also proved that some of the improvement required needs to come from the dugout as well.
O’Neill’s post-match admission only makes some of those decisions harder to understand.
He deserves credit for immediately saying he would look at “my own part in proceedings”, but his explanation that he “wanted people to experience this atmosphere” really caught my attention.
Martin, this wasn’t a pre-season friendly or an opportunity to give players a wee taste of Ibrox. This was Rangers away in a League Cup quarter-final.
Celtic were there to win, not provide an experience.
New signings will get plenty of opportunities to discover what this fixture is all about, but when there’s a place in a semi-final at stake, I want our strongest available team selected for one reason and one reason only: to beat Rangers.
Ultimately, O’Neill can point towards Celtic being “well short” all he likes, but today he became part of the problem.
His team selection was wrong, his setup failed, his changes did nothing to rescue the game and describing a cup quarter-final at Ibrox as an opportunity for players to “experience this atmosphere” simply isn’t good enough.
Celtic weren’t there for a learning experience — they were there to knock Rangers out.
O’Neill has spent the week demanding more from this Celtic team. After a 3-0 defeat in which Rangers thoroughly deserved to progress, the harsh reality is that the manager failed his own standards too.
He got the biggest domestic game of the season badly wrong, and no warning about the limitations of his squad should be allowed to disguise that.














Comments.
Loading comments…