The Celtic VAR row has somehow found another gear — and this time even Bobby Madden is questioning what happened.
Let me make one thing clear from the start. I am no Bobby Madden admirer. I rarely agree with his opinions on refereeing decisions, and I would not normally build an argument around his verdict.
Madden’s Rangers connections from his younger days are also well documented by the man himself. He previously revealed that his grandfather was a “massive Rangers fan” who took him to Ibrox until he was around 12 or 13.
That is precisely why his latest intervention is worth noting.
Celtic VAR row takes another twist
Rangers beat St Mirren 1-0 at Ibrox on Wednesday night, but with the game still goalless, Emmanuel Fernandez caught Ismael Kabia inside the penalty area. No penalty was awarded.
Former FIFA referee Madden believes that decision was wrong.
He argued that Fernandez failed to play the ball and made sufficient contact for a penalty under UEFA guidance. Former Rangers midfielder Andy Halliday also believed VAR should have intervened.
This is where Celtic supporters are entitled to ask serious questions.
Just days earlier, Celtic had two goals disallowed against the same St Mirren side during a match plagued by VAR controversy and technical problems.
Then, against St Johnstone, Haissem Hassan had another goal disallowed after the assistant decided the ball had crossed the byline before Kasper Høgh headed it back.
VAR could not conclusively establish whether the ball had actually gone out. Therefore, officials stayed with the on-field decision. Even Kris Boyd believed the ball had remained in play.
Celtic VAR row demands consistency
That principle sounds reasonable. VAR should only overturn an on-field decision when there is clear evidence.
However, consistency is the problem.
At Ibrox, St Mirren had an incident Madden regarded as a penalty. Referee Don Robertson did not award it and VAR Steven McLean did not overturn him. Rangers eventually scored in the 91st minute to win 1-0.
This is not about claiming conspiracy. It is about demanding the same standards.
I do not suddenly regard Bobby Madden as the ultimate authority because his opinion happens to support my argument. Far from it. I usually disagree with him and, given his own history of attending Ibrox as a youngster, he certainly isn’t someone I would normally reach for when making a Celtic case.
That actually makes this more striking.
When even Madden looks at an incident involving Rangers and concludes St Mirren should have received a penalty, Scottish football should pay attention.
Celtic have now seen three goals disallowed across two matches amid arguments over what VAR can and cannot conclusively prove.
Supporters deserve consistency.
Right now, they are getting anything but.














Comments.
Loading comments…