Skip to content

Why Do We As Fans Judge Scottish Players So Differently?

Share

Why Do We As Fans Judge Scottish Players So Differently?

There are few things guaranteed to divide the Celtic support quite like a Scottish player.

One week, Anthony Ralston is reportedly close to signing a new contract, and the reaction is mixed.

Next, people are asking whether he’s good enough to play another minute for the club.

Sound familiar?

Because we watched exactly the same thing happen with Greg Taylor.

For months his contract became one of the biggest talking points surrounding Celtic. Some wanted him kept at all costs. Others couldn’t wait to move him on.

It raises an interesting question.

DINGWALL, SCOTLAND – DECEMBER 15: Celtic’s Anthony Ralston celebrates making it 2-1 during a cinch Premiership match between Ross County and Celtic at the Global Energy Stadium, on December 15, 2021, in Dingwall, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Foy/SNS Group via Getty Images)

Why do we judge Scottish players so differently?

The “He’s One Of Us” Effect

Scottish players rarely get judged solely on football.

They’re judged on emotion.

Supporters see themselves in them.

Anthony Ralston isn’t just a right-back.

He’s a boy who came through the academy.

He’s lived the dream every supporter imagined as a kid.

That creates patience.

Loyalty.

Sometimes even protection.

Foreign players don’t often get that luxury.

If a £3 million signing struggles for six months, supporters quickly ask questions.

If an academy graduate struggles, the conversation becomes far more emotional.

Or Maybe We Judge Them Even Harder

Then again, perhaps it’s actually the opposite.

Because supporters know Scottish football so well, expectations become unrealistic.

Greg Taylor was never going to replace Kieran Tierney.

Anthony Ralston was never going to surpass Danny McGrain’s legacy.

Yet at times they’re judged against impossible standards.

Taylor won multiple league titles, adapted brilliantly to Ange Postecoglou’s inverted full-back role and became a Scotland international.

Yet every transfer window seemed to involve replacing him.

Ralston has spent years accepting his role as backup, stepping in whenever asked and never creating problems.

Yet every new contract debate with a Scottish player quickly becomes, “Is he Celtic quality?”

Would we ask those same questions if they were Scandinavian?

Or Japanese?

I’m not convinced we would.

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND – FEBRUARY 17: David Turnbull of Celtic celebrates after he scores the only goal of the game during the Ladbrokes Scottish Premiership match between Celtic and Aberdeen at Celtic Park on February 17, 2021 in Glasgow, Scotland. Sporting stadiums around the UK remain under strict restrictions due to the Coronavirus Pandemic as Government social distancing laws prohibit fans inside venues resulting in games being played behind closed doors. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

I remember the same with David Turnbull a few years ago. A great midfielder who scored goals, but we felt we could “get better”.

The Passport Test

Sometimes it feels like Scottish players need to do more to earn the same appreciation.

If a foreign signing works hard, supporters praise the mentality.

If a Scottish player does exactly the same, it’s often dismissed as simply “giving effort”.

Local players often become defined by mistakes.

Anthony Ralston’s winner at Ross County under Ange Postecoglou helped change the course of a title race.

Yet mention his name and many supporters still immediately think about mistakes rather than moments like that.

The same happened with Greg Taylor.

Years of consistency.

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND – FEBRUARY 12: Michael Olise of Bayern Munich runs with the ball whilst under pressure from Greg Taylor of Celtic during the UEFA Champions League 2024/25 League Knockout Play-off First Leg match between Celtic FC and FC Bayern München at Celtic Park on February 12, 2025 in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by S. Mellar/FC Bayern via Getty Images)

He gets megged by Olise in the Champions League, and there are debates about whether he should be “doing better”.

Maybe We Need More Balance

This isn’t about saying every Scottish player should stay.

Nor is it about handing out contracts because someone came through the academy.

Celtic should always demand the highest standards.

But perhaps we should judge everyone by those same standards.

Because if Anthony Ralston signs a new deal, it should represent a success for the academy and for the player himself, not stagnation in the momentum of the playing squad.

Key Takeaways

  • Celtic fans often have mixed feelings about Scottish players like Anthony Ralston and Greg Taylor, reflecting emotional connections.
  • Scottish players face higher scrutiny, judged not just on performance but on expectations tied to their backgrounds.
  • Supporters may apply unrealistic standards to local talent compared to foreign recruits, raising questions of fairness.
  • The appreciation of Scottish players can diminish despite significant contributions, like Ralston’s key moments.
  • A more balanced approach to judgement could benefit both players and the club’s academy.

Jump to comments

Aodhán Ó Conchobhair started writing in 2025. A lifelong Celtic supporter, now living in London after graduating from Strathclyde University in 2024. Before getting into writing, Aidan worked as a talent ID academy scout with Hibernian, where he managed their London network, covering age groups from U15 through to U21 level. That role had him regularly watching youth football, tracking development, and helping identify players who could make the step up into professional environments. It gave him a strong grounding in how clubs actually operate behind the scenes when it comes to recruitment and academy pathways. In 2025, he moved into writing and quickly began contributing to Celtic-focused fan media. His articles have featured in both The Celtic Way and The Celtic Cynic, where he’s built a reputation for informed analytical pieces.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.