Every summer there’s one name that feels tailor-made for us.
This summer, for me, that name is Elijah Just.

And the worst part is, I can already picture how this ends.
We’ve already seen him light up the World Cup. And we’ll watch some mid-table side in the Bundesliga or the Eredivisie do the obvious bit of business. And then we’ll read the quotes about “the model” and how the recruitment team “had him on the list”.
We always have them on the list.
That’s never been the problem.
What Just Did At The World Cup
Let’s start with what’s actually in front of us.
This is a player who just scored twice at a World Cup for New Zealand.
He broke records doing it – the first New Zealander to score more than once at a World Cup.
Does He Fit The Profile? Almost Suspiciously Well
Here’s where it gets frustrating.
Because Just isn’t some left-field punt. He ticks every single box on the recruitment sheet the club won’t stop reminding us about.
Young enough to develop.
Already proven at a level above the SPFL and has shown an ability to perform above the level.
A direct, two-footed wide forward who can play off either flank or through the middle.
And available now for a fee whose resale value would be swallowed whole in eighteen months.
The whole “model” is built on it. Buy the talent before the market catches up. Develop it. Sell it for a profit. Reinvest. We’ve been lectured about this cycle for years like it’s some sacred text.
Well.

A 26-year-old who just announced himself to every sporting director on the planet.
At a price that only goes one direction after a tournament like that.
He is the model.
The Standard Question – Is He Actually Celtic Level?
Look, I’m not going to insult anyone’s intelligence here.

I’ve asked this exact question before about wide players we already have at the club.
So it’s only fair I ask it about Just.
Is he the finished article? No.
Will he need a season to settle into the relentlessness of chasing a title where one dropped point becomes a crisis? Probably.
Celtic wingers have always lived and died by one thing. End product. Goals and assists, not flashes and “glimpses”.
But here’s the difference between Just and the rotation options we keep settling for.
He’s already shown the end product when it mattered most.
You don’t score twice at a World Cup on flashes.
You score twice at a World Cup because, in the biggest moments of your life, you delivered.
That’s the exact attribute we keep saying we can’t find.
We had it in front of us all season.
This Isn’t About One Player. It’s about a pattern.
And this is the real issue.
Because if it were just Just, you could shrug it off. One player, one window, one of those things.
But it’s never just one player, is it?
We’ve made an art form out of identifying talent and then standing perfectly still.
The promising winger who “didn’t fit the budget”.
The midfielder we were “monitoring” right up until he signed for someone with actual conviction.
The defender we “explored” before deciding deadline day was a better time to panic.
Different windows. Different targets. Same ending.
For me, that’s the thread running through all of this. It’s not that the recruitment team can’t spot a player. It’s that spotting one and signing one have become two completely separate departments at this club.
And supporters have noticed.
Postecoglou Already Told Them. They Didn’t Listen.
We don’t need an outsider to make this argument. Our own former manager made it, on the record, years ago.
Back at the 2022 AGM, Ange Postecoglou stood up and told the board exactly what was required.
His words. “We can make gains by being aggressive and agile in the transfer market.”
Aggressive. And agile.
He said clubs our size “regenerate” every couple of years. That we had to “push forward aggressively”. He understood that a club like ours doesn’t catch the elite by outspending them – it catches them by moving faster and braver than everyone else for the players that matter.
And it’s funny, isn’t it, how that line has aged…
Because the same board that nodded along at the AGM is the one that now treats “agile” as a dirty word and “aggressive” as something that happens to the wage bill.
Postecoglou handed them the blueprint on a plate.
Elijah Just is exactly the kind of move that blueprint was written for.
So Are The Fans Wrong To Be Raging?
No.
Not even slightly.
Because frustration isn’t entitlement. Frustration is what happens when you watch the same mistake on a loop and get told it’s a plan.
Supporters aren’t asking the club to sign every player that is in the SPL that shows promise. They’re asking the club to act like it believes its own slogans. To be the aggressive, agile club Postecoglou described instead of the cautious, penny-pinching one we keep watching.
When a player this suited to us moves elsewhere for a fee we could’ve covered out of the couch cushions, the anger isn’t irrational.
It’s the only sane response left.
The Bottom Line
For me, this one matters beyond the player.
If we sign Just, great. The model works. You can talk about “aggressive and agile” without the irony.
If we don’t – if he lands at some side with a fraction of our history and twice our nerve – then spare us the AGM speeches about “ambition” next time.
Because it doesn’t just cost us a winger.
It tells every supporter watching that nothing has actually changed.
And that’s the part I’m dreading.
Key Takeaways
- Elijah Just scored twice at the World Cup for New Zealand, breaking records and proving he delivers on the sport’s biggest stage – the exact attribute Celtic claim they search for.
- He fits the club’s stated recruitment model perfectly: young enough to develop, proven above SPFL level, two-footed and versatile, and available at a fee that would be dwarfed by his resale value.
- Whether Celtic pursue him is a test of strategy, not scouting – the club’s recurring failure is identifying talent and then failing to act on it aggressively.
- Ange Postecoglou warned the board back at the 2022 AGM that Celtic must be “aggressive and agile” in the market to compete in Europe; this is exactly the kind of move he meant.
- There are valid reasons a recruitment team might pass – medicals, wages, release clauses, faith in younger options – but the board’s refusal to ever explain them is why supporter frustration is justified.
- If Celtic let a player this tailor-made walk away, it will only deepen the criticism of the club’s decision-making in the transfer market.













Comments.
Loading comments…