Skip to content

Steve Clarke Is Out The Race, Robbie Keane Is In?,Martin O’Neill May Be Back? But Are We All Hoping For A Mystery Name?

Share

One manager can officially be crossed off the list.

Steve Clarke won’t be walking through the door.

His new Scotland contract has effectively ended that conversation before it properly started.

I’m not sure many supporters will lose sleep over it.

Good Scotland manager.

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND – AUGUST 15: Scotland manager Steve Clarke is seen in attendance prior to the Premier Sports League Cup match between Celtic and Falkirk at Celtic Park on August 15, 2025 in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

Done a solid job internationally.

But managing Scotland and managing us are two completely different jobs.

One involves seeing players four times a year.

The other involves surviving a full season with Yang and Tounekti as your first choice wingers.

So with Clarke gone, the rumour mill rolls on.

Robbie Keane: A former Bhoy

On one hand, he has coaching experience.

He’s been involved in winning environments.

He understands British football.

BUDAPEST, HUNGARY – DECEMBER 11: Robbie Keane, Head Coach of Ferencvarosi TC, celebrates after the team’s victory in the UEFA Europa League 2025/26 League Phase MD6 match between Ferencvarosi TC and Rangers FC at Ferencvaros Stadion on December 11, 2025 in Budapest, Hungary. (Photo by David Balogh/Getty Images)

On the other hand, if somebody had told you twelve months ago that Robbie Keane would be linked with the job, you’d be bitterly disappointed. 

I’m straggly to fully embrace the idea of him as a manager for us. 

I think if he is appointed, it will really split our support. 

For me, he’s too inexperienced and just a risky an appointment as Nancy was.

Martin O’Neill 4th spell?

Then there’s Martin.

Again.

After what happened this season, it’s difficult to completely dismiss the possibility.

The pros:

Won the League.

Restores the dressing room.

United supporters, team, and board (for a period)

A squad that looked dead somehow dragged over the finish line.

The counterargument is obvious too.

Age.

Long-term planning.

Whether he actually wants the stress.

Whether the club wants to build around a manager in his seventies.

I’ve already made my feelings clear on the age discussion.

If somebody keeps winning football matches, I really couldn’t care less what age they are.

The older he gets, the younger he seems.

Or Is The Answer Somebody Nobody Has Mentioned Yet?

This is the option I suspect most supporters want.

Not Clarke.

Or Keane.

Not necessarily O’Neill.

An actual football decision.

A proper recruitment process.

A name nobody spends three weeks leaking to newspapers first.

The best appointments usually aren’t the obvious ones.

Nobody was demanding Ange Postecoglou.

Most people had never heard of him.

Then he changed the entire direction of the club.

People resonated with his story and immigrant upbringing.

He brought us players that never would have came to the club without him.

Damn… I miss that man… ffs

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND – MAY 27: Celtic’s Kyogo Furuhashi and Ange Postecoglou (R) with the trophy at full time during a cinch Premiership match between Celtic and Aberdeen at Celtic Park, on May 27, 2023, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Williamson/SNS Group via Getty Images)

However. 

The problem is trusting this board to find that person.

And that’s where the anxiety comes from.

Because this isn’t a normal summer.

New manager.

A major rebuild.

Potentially £100 million-plus worth of squad turnover. 

Get it right and everything becomes easier.

Get it wrong and we’ll be back here discussing another rebuild in twelve months.

What Most Supporters Are Actually Hoping For

I don’t think supporters necessarily want a specific name.

I think they want competence.

A plan.

Evidence that somebody inside the club has actually learned from the mistakes of recent years.

Because after Rodgers.

Nancy.

O’Neill’s rescue mission.

After all the boardroom chaos.

Nobody wants another experiment.

We want the right person.

Whoever that is.

Key Takeaways

  • Steve Clarke’s new contract with Scotland rules him out as a candidate for Celtic’s managerial position.
  • Robbie Keane’s inexperience raises concerns, despite his coaching background in winning environments.
  • Martin O’Neill is a potential candidate, but age and long-term planning pose significant questions.
  • Supporters desire a thoughtful recruitment process, looking for a manager who can align with the club’s vision.
  • Competence and a clear plan are essential for fans, especially after recent managerial changes and turmoil.

Jump to comments

Aodhán Ó Conchobhair started writing in 2025. A lifelong Celtic supporter, now living in London after graduating from Strathclyde University in 2024. Before getting into writing, Aidan worked as a talent ID academy scout with Hibernian, where he managed their London network, covering age groups from U15 through to U21 level. That role had him regularly watching youth football, tracking development, and helping identify players who could make the step up into professional environments. It gave him a strong grounding in how clubs actually operate behind the scenes when it comes to recruitment and academy pathways. In 2025, he moved into writing and quickly began contributing to Celtic-focused fan media. His articles have featured in both The Celtic Way and The Celtic Cynic, where he’s built a reputation for informed analytical pieces.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.