Skip to content

Dom McKay v Silent Mike – Dom McKay achieved more for Celtic in 76 days than Silent Mike has in 5 years. Therein lies the problem at our club…

Share

Dom McKay v Silent Mike – Dom McKay achieved more for Celtic in 76 days than Silent Mike has in 5 years. Therein lies the problem at our club…

There has been a lot of talk over the last couple of days around Dom McKay and his short tenure as CEO at Celtic.

Nothing revealing per se, but he has been returned to our thought stream for obvious reasons.

Everybody seems to have a sense of foreboding in relation to the summer ahead.

The signs have been pretty ominous so far since the Scottish Cup made its way back to Celtic Park last weekend.

As a result, the Celtic support is pining for someone like Dom McKay to be our CEO.

And many are wondering what our club would have looked like now if he had been allowed to continue building what he was building.

Instead, after securing a double despite the handicaps this board put on our club last season, we are witnessing the same spiteful attitude from the Celtic board headed into this summer.

The board have commenced their attack on the Green Brigade once again, with the intent of sowing division in the support before we are any where near the start of next season.

See the below from the GB:

This document speaks for itself.

I don’t need to elaborate on it, but it proves clearly that this Celtic board has learnt absolutely from the calamities of the season just gone.

Nor do they seem willing to.

Sowing division seems to be a sport to them – and antagonising the support – a hobby for their enjoyment.

They have proven that they just used the Green Brigade to aid in getting the double we just achieved over the line.

Now they have reverted to type.

What is that type?

A vacuous, utterly stupid group of individuals who really believe that this club is their plaything.

To do with what they wish.

This is what we are forced to trust in at Celtic.

How can you trust a group of individuals who cannot even get the basic requirement of hiring a manager right?

For a while yesterday, the below post on X was doing the rounds, then it was subsequently deleted:

It had 47.9k views, and was apparently reposted 77 times.

The question is, is it a fabrication, or was it real?

If it was, then why was it deleted?

If the Celtic board is looking for a tipping point, the appointment of Robbie Keane would be the right way to go about it.

Ferencvaros’ Irish coach Robbie Keane grimaces before the UEFA Europa League last 16 second leg football match between SC Braga and Ferencvaros at Municipal stadium of Braga on March 18, 2026. (Photo by Miguel RIOPA / AFP via Getty Images)

I think it’s fair to say that there is very little of our support who would accept Keane as our manager.

As I stated before, he would be a Desmond appointment, and appointed simply because of his nationality, and not his skill set.

In reality, only one individual would want him as the manager of Celtic.

But I believe the appointment of this individual would send the support over the edge.

Into all out rebellion.

That is how little we want him at Celtic.

Which brings me back to Dom McKay.

I digressed slightly there, but I felt those extra points needed to be made.

A lot of media outlets and fan media produced stories about the former Celtic CEO yesterday.

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND – AUGUST 12: Celtic Chief Executive Dom McKay and Chairman Ian Bankier during a UEFA Europa League 2nd Leg Qualifer between Celtic and Jablonec at Celtic Park, on August 12, 2021, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Photo by Craig Williamson/SNS Group via Getty Images)

I think in hindsight, it is now fair to say that Dom McKay achieved more in his short 76 day tenure at Celtic than Michael Nicholson has achieved in the 5 years since his departure.

We experienced the one of the best transfer windows in our modern history under McKay.

Which has since been well and truly asset stripped by the current incumbent in the Celtic boardroom.

Dom McKay gave us a glimpse of what this club could achieve under the right leadership.

Today, we long for that kind of leadership.

We look back on McKay’s short sojourn at our club, and we imagine what our club could have been under his stewardship.

Instead, we got Michael Nicholson.

And today, we’re still actually wondering what we got.

Because in all honesty, a cardboard cut out would achieve more than Nicholson has achieved as CEO of our great club.

And a cardboard cut out would probably have more charisma than Silent Mike.

It really seems to me that this board is hell bent on the destruction of our club.

Or more to the point, hell bent on the destruction of our support as we know it.

When Dom McKay took over at Celtic, he immediately set about engaging with all supporter groups.

In addition to that, he opened the doors to fan media in a way they had never been opened before.

Which makes you wonder…

When you take into consideration the abominable way our support has been treated by the current board in the last year or so, was McKay’s engagement with us one of the reasons his tenure was ended so abruptly?

The way they lashed out at us at the AGM?

And the way they banned fan media, and still haven’t re-opened the doors to fan media since?

Are these men, who claim they bleed for Celtic, so blinded by their hatred of the club’s support, that they have to treat us like dirt?

What is their problem with the Celtic support?

Dom McKay believed in unity at the club.

Unlike Brian Wilson, who only bullshits about unity.

Because if he actually meant what he said, there would be continued galvanisation and engagement with the support.

But instead, the board has engaged in sowing further division.

Showing that no lessons have been from learnt from last season.

Nor will lessons ever be learnt under these charlatans.

Celtic will continue on a doom spiral as long as they remain in control.

There is no point in pretending otherwise.

But we cannot continue to accept it.

If they continue to wage petty battles with the support, and then antagonise us further with an appointment like Robbie Keane, there should be hell to pay.

We need to make them realise that last season’s protests will have been tame in comparison to what’s to come.

They’ve caused everything that’s wrong at Celtic right now.

Which is why every one of us wishes we had someone like Dom McKay in control at our club.

We are doomed to repeat the same mistakes over, and over, again with these charlatans in charge.

Nothing will change.

As predicted, they really believe they’re off the hook after Martin and the boys delivered the double.

They really think the Celtic support is something malleable.

Something they can manipulate into their way of thinking.

Their way of thinking is outdated by over 20 years.

The ironic thing is that they’re the only ones who can’t see that.

They have no vision, no plan, and really, no support.

They are still, and always will be, the most hated board in Celtic’s modern history.

And to think it could have been so different if they’d allowed a man with vision to take the club forward 5 years ago?

We can only dream about where we’d be now if Dom McKay was still at the club.

That’s really all we’re left with.

Because we can never look forward under this board.

Key Takeaways

  • Dom McKay’s short tenure as CEO at Celtic left fans wondering what could have been under his leadership.
  • The current Celtic board continues to sow division among supporters instead of fostering unity and engagement.
  • Fans express frustration over the board’s lack of vision and poor treatment of support since McKay’s departure.
  • The potential appointment of Robbie Keane as manager raises concerns among supporters, indicating a lack of desirable leadership choices.
  • Many supporters long for Dom McKay’s approach, as the current management’s actions lead to a sense of impending doom for the club.

Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.