Skip to content

As Celtic suffered from more baffling decisions yesterday, its clear referees will have a huge influence on this season’s title

Share

As Celtic suffered from more baffling decisions yesterday, its clear referees will have a huge influence on this season’s title

There really isn’t a weekend that goes by in Scottish football where the referees aren’t mired in one controversial decision or another, and Celtic Park was no exception yesterday.

The Trusty red card, on balance, was probably deserved.

I stated this in my morning article, and I’m not inclined to change my view on it.

Some people think it wasn’t and that McGrath made a meal of it, which he did.

But I think it was the force that Trusty used to dislodge McGrath that did for him.

I can understand that at that point in the game frustrations were starting to boil over.

This holding tactic during corner kicks is becoming more and more prevalent in the game this season.

In reality, the referees should be adopting a zero tolerance for it.

But they don’t, and because they don’t you end up with incidents like yesterday’s when it keeps happening.

However, while you might understand the decision to send off Trusty somewhat, I fail to understand how the incident involving Liam Scales was not deemed to be a penalty.

It is clear that when the Celtic corner is taken, Scales is attempting to get himself into a goalscoring position.

Which is made impossible by the way he is impeded, and then hauled to the ground by Jack Iredale.

It is then reviewed on VAR by Grant Irvine, and is inexplicably deemed to be no penalty as it the incident was “outside the box”.

Now, we can clearly see it wasn’t outside the box, it was very much inside it.

So that had to be a mistake, surely?

And if it was a mistake, what was the real reason for denying Celtic a penalty, as it looked pretty clear cut to me?

Now I’m not saying that if we’d got the penalty and scored from it, we’d have won the game.

But if we had, it would most likely have been the difference between winning or losing the game.

The worst case scenario would have been a draw.

And 1 point for Celtic, rather than none could have turned out to be precious.

But it wasn’t just Celtic Park where there were inexplicable decisions over the weekend just gone.

At Livingston, consistency certainly didn’t seem to be the order of the day.

After Cristian Montano was sent off with a straight red for a foul on Djeidi Gassama, its a mystery how Cammy Kerr stayed on the pitch for his tackle on Mikey Moore at the death.

Just to note, the Ibrox side got 11 minutes of injury time to salvage a win from a dire draw.

They didn’t take advantage of it.

But I’ll be honest and say that while they might not have deserved a penalty for the Mikey Moore incident due to the fact it was outside the box, it was definitely a foul.

Therefore should have been a sending off.

You’ll rarely catch me advocating for the Ibrox side, but I have to call this one as it is.

What baffles me even more is that David Dickinson didn’t jump on that one?

(Photo by Ross Parker/SNS Group via Getty Images)

But finally, and the one that tops them all off is the incident in Paisley in the St. Mirren v Motherwell game.

If you thought that the Trusty incident was bad, this one is utterly ridiculous.

Referee Callum Scott fell for Motherwell player Callum Slattery’s histrionics hook, line, and sinker when he sent off St. Mirren’s Richard King.

First and foremost, the foul in this situation was committed by Slattery to begin with.

Once again, it involved jersey tugging, or arm tugging, its hard to tell exactly.

Slattery hangs on to King’s arm as he’s walking away, and King tries to struggle free from his grip.

When he eventually does, his momentum swings him around, where he literally waves his arm in Slattery’s face, making zero contact with the Motherwell player.

Slattery hits the deck, and referee Scott reaches for the red.

What defies belief in this decision, is the fact that VAR didn’t even look at this and tell Scott to book Slattery for simulation.

It was an appalling decision, and appalling behaviour from Callum Slattery.

(Photo by Craig Foy/SNS Group via Getty Images)

Not that it would have changed the outcome of the game, as the Steelmen were already 3 up at that point.

But it took away any hope St. Mirren might have had.

And they certainly did not deserve that.

All in all, it was shocking weekend for complete ineptitude from the SFA’s officials.

It really does paint our game as farcical when it comes to some of the decisions referees are making this season.

The worst thing about it is that this poor decision making is eventually going to cost someone very heavily in this title run in.

If this season is not the catalyst for refereeing reform, its doubtful it will ever happen.

I have no idea what we even have VAR in our game for.

When you see some of the decisions over the weekend, it appears about as useful as a set of pedals on a wheelchair.

I just can’t figure out why the clubs keep accepting it.

That is the baffling thing here.

I dread to think what we’re going to face next weekend.

Or who we’re going to face for that matter.

Has Dickinson’s time come?

God help us if it has.

They’ll probably stick with old Mr. Reliable for this one.

Beaton for the League game, and Dickinson for the Cup tie.

Wait and see…

Key Takeaways

  • Celtic Park experienced another controversial refereeing decision, particularly regarding the Trusty red card which many felt was justified.
  • A lack of consistency with VAR decisions left Celtic without a clear penalty after Scales was fouled in the box.
  • Scottish football sees ongoing issues with referees not applying zero tolerance to holding tactics during set pieces.
  • The shocking officiating over the weekend also included dubious red cards in other matches, raising questions about refereeing standards.
  • Overall, the ineptitude of SFA officials seems set to impact the title race, highlighting the need for reform in officiating.

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.