Skip to content

Celtic, Nancy and the Debate Over Giving Managers Time

Share

Celtic, Nancy and the Debate Over Giving Managers Time

It’s not controversial to say that Wilfred Nancy’s start to life at Celtic has been a difficult one. The Frenchman has yet to find his feet, causing some to question the appointment. Of course, it doesn’t help matters that Martin O’Neill did so well as caretaker before Nancy came on board, but the truth remains that he has had one of the worst starts to the job in the club’s history. Indeed, he statistically has the worst managerial win-rate in Celtic history.

Yet, rather than debate the merits of Nancy’s short tenure, we wanted to discuss the broader issue of sticking with managers. It’s a hot-button topic, and it’s certainly not one that is limited to Celtic at the moment. The question of giving managers time tends to divide opinion, and it often feels like something that is more obvious in hindsight.

No right answer in general on the “time” issue

The first thing to say is that there seems to be no right answer about what the right solution is. Moreover, it tends to be different for each club and its setup. For example, Real Madrid is a club that seems to be able to cope with changing managers regularly without upsetting the rhythm of the club too much, but that’s probably down to the coach’s limited flexibility compared to other clubs. At Madrid, you are a head coach, not a manager.

Nonetheless, there are interesting discussions to be had: At Manchester United, it has been intriguing to see the support for Ruben Amorim from the club’s owners, with Jim Ratcliffe recently saying that he (Amorim) needs three years to show his true worth. We always take owners’ backing with a pinch of salt, of course, but perhaps “Sir Jim,” a long-time United fan, wants to recreate the kind of magic that happened in the club’s past with Alex Ferguson, who was famously ‘almost’ sacked before his long-term period of success ensued.

Of course, some coaches hit the ground running. Claudio Ranieri’s arrival at Leicester in 2015 was met with raised eyebrows, but he guided the Foxes to the most improbable title in the history of football without ever needing any bedding-in period. Instant transformations occur in other sports, too. Mike Vrabel, for instance, has turned the American football team the New England Patriots into contenders in the NFL Super Bowl odds in his first season, instantly winning the adoration of the fans. It can simply just happen.

Coaches need to show there is a blueprint

The problem, however, is that when discussing all of this in a general sense, you don’t always know whether sticking with the manager is going to make things worse. There have been studies done on this in an attempt to parse out the data, and at best, they can be described as inconclusive. Sometimes sticking by the manager works, and sometimes it doesn’t. The problem is that it sometimes takes a few managerial changes to work out that the problem might be beyond a coaching one; again, see Manchester United for evidence.

As we said, this should not be viewed as a discussion of Nancy’s short, difficult life so far at Celtic, but it does follow that at the very least we should be seeing some underlying improvements in the team or at least a sense of trajectory that something is being built. You could see that in the early days of Jurgen Klopp at Liverpool and Mikel Arteta at Arsenal, who, despite not great results in their initial months, could point to the blueprint for success – the “process” as Arteta calls it.

And that, for sure, is what Celtic fans should be looking at with Nancy over the coming weeks and months. In a sense, it does not matter if Hearts or Rangers win the title (well, of course it does, but not in terms of Nancy’s future). What matters in terms of giving him time is if the board and fans see some semblance of a trajectory of where he brings the team. If that does not become apparent in the coming months, well, someone will have Martin O’Neill’s telephone number.

Image Source: Pixabay

Jump to comments

Jonathan Fear has been working in the sports and football industry for over twenty years, building a large football network and then specialising in guest features for clients across the globe. A long standing fan of football and sport and a long suffering fan of Aston Villa, Jonathan has written over 10 000 articles as well as being often quoted in the national press, and on SkySports and local BBC TV and radio stations.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.