For as long as we can remember, well, at least for the entire duration of the 21st century, the Celtic board has always prided itself on the club’s transfer trading model.
The strategy of buying low and selling high has made us look like some kind of financial behemoth.
But in order for that strategy to work, every so often, a chunk of gold had to be found hidden amongst the dirty copper.
Luckily for the Celtic board, they had an uncanny knack of finding that chunk of gold when they needed to.
In most, if not all cases, when they did, their eagerness to cash in has been to the detriment of the first team squad.
I would even go so far as to say that this strategy has caused managers to leave the club.
Neil Lennon became tired of the constant asset stripping of his squad when he left for the first time in 2014.
We know that the 2018 summer transfer window, combined with the sale of Moussa Dembele and the failure to secure John McGinn, was the catalyst to Brendan Rodgers leaving.
The 2025 summer window for Celtic, and the resultant fallout thereafter, speaks for itself.
This board has actually spent more time sabotaging managers than it has backing them, if we’re being honest here.
So, why then, should we expect anything different from them in the upcoming January transfer window?
Well, I would say first and foremost that they have asset stripped the current squad beyond the point of no return.
There are two, maybe three, major assets remaining in the first team squad.
And by that, I mean players who will fetch us serious money in the transfer market.
The first names that come to mind are obviously Daizen Maeda and Reo Hatate.
After that, the only other assets of note are Alistair Johnston and Cameron Carter-Vickers.
But I fear we may be gone beyond the point of no return when it comes to cashing in on the US international.
CCV’s age, and the fact that he is so injury prone, probably means that we might now just about scrape back what we paid for him.
Any kind of valuation on Alistair Johnston is on hold due to his whole season being beset with injury.
We might not even see him before the end of this season.
Felipe Jota also has to restart his career once he returns from injury.
Therefore, putting a value on him is also pointless at this moment in time.
If we were to sell Maeda and Hatate in the January window, which would not surprise me at all, then we are officially at ground zero.
And by that, I mean we have no serious assets remaining in the Celtic first team squad.

Assets that will fetch us an eight figure sum.
If we do, then I’m open to contradiction, but I don’t see it.
You would have thought that the hiring of a Head of Football Operations just over a year ago would have been designed to ensure we did not find ourselves at this juncture?
The board wanted asset stripping continued, and Paul Tisdale’s remit would have been to ensure the players required to do that were sourced.
It seems that the football doctor understood the concept of buying low, but it would appear that’s where his skillset ends.
We spent a paltry £11 million in the summer transfer window to acquire Callum Osmand, Benjamin Nygren, Shin Yamada, Hyato Inamura, Sebastian Tounekti, and Michel-Ange Balikwisha.
The rest of the players acquired were either free transfers, or loans, with little or no resale value.
We knew Kieran Tierney would be joining Celtic since January 2025.
Out of those we spent the £11 million on, Benjamin Nygren is the only one showing any promise.
He might fetch a decent seven figure sum a year or two from now.
After 6 months which wasted both his time, £250k, and our time, it would appear Hyato Inamura is returning to his native Japan to play for Tokyo FC.
We questioned this transfer on the Trinity Tims podcast when Inamura arrived.
Needless to say, it has turned out exactly as we expected it would.
Sebastian Tounekti showed some early promise, but has since morphed into a poor man’s version of Mikey Johnston.
If Michel-Ange Balikwisha is going to contribute anything of value, I’ve yet to see it.
Shin Yamada cannot buy a goal, no matter how hard he tries.
If someone thought he was the next Kyogo Furuhashi, they were sorely mistaken.
As bad and all as Kyogo has been since he departed Celtic, he has still scored a goal this season in the League Cup for Birmingham City.
Its one more than Yamada has managed since joined Celtic.
Callum Osmand did show some early promise during Martin O’Neill’s interim tenure.
But that was brought to a swift halt due to injury in our Europa League game against Midtjylland.
We’ve yet to see what he can really contribute, and we’ll be waiting a while until he recovers from his hamstring injury.
At this moment in time, Celtic’s player trading model is defunct.
It is defunct thanks entirely to the man who calls himself the football doctor, Paul Tisdale.
His summer foray into the transfer market, Benjamin Nygren aside, has not delivered another player of note or decent resale value.
Michel-Ange Balikwisha and Sebastian Tounekti have probably devalued since they joined us last August.
This is why this January’s window is now critical for Celtic, for so many reasons.
If the board and Tisdale do not get this window 100% right, the fallout is going to be incalcuable.
There will be a decent chance we will not win this season’s title.
The transfer trading model the board prided itself so much on, will be officially dead in the water.
If we do not win the title, fans will not buy into the non-strategic, visionless plan that the board has.
Season ticket sales will plummet, merchandise sales are already plummeting.
Without players who could fetch decent prices in the transfer market, there is no way of making up the financial shortfall caused by the decline in revenues from season ticket sales, and merchandise sales.
It all becomes a vicious cycle, with the club devouring itself from within financially.
Not winning the league would also contribute to further devaluing our players.
Put simply, winners fetch more than losers in any transfer market.
For the better part of this century, Celtic has been reliant on our dominance to contribute to the value of our players.
Our dominance has also afforded us the ability to play in Europe’s Premier competition.
Losing that dominance will result in us losing credibility in the transfer market.
Because winning in Scotland is the only real credibility you have.
Anything outside of that, and you are a non-entity, invisible to the rest of the serious footballing world.
So, you can see clearly now why this January’s transfer window is the most important window in a long, long time for Celtic.
What’s even more worrying is the people who are now tasked with ensuring this window has to be a resounding success.
These are the very same people who deliberately sabotaged Brendan Rodgers in the summer transfer window.
We are in this mess because of the incompetence of Paul Tisdale, and Michael Nicholson.
Now we are expected to trust them to land us the players we need to ensure we win this season’s title?
Forgive me if I might struggle to sleep at night at the thoughts of that.
I’ll conclude my article with these very sobering thoughts.
In the space of one season, the staggering incompetence of the Celtic board, and Dermot Desmond, has brought the club to the verge of disaster.
The cronyism and nepotism of this board has brought us to our knees.

If ever you needed concrete evidence of that, look no further than Paul Tisdale.
Then look at the collateral damage his appointment has caused.
The irony in all of this is that their famous transfer trading model, asset stripping to you and me, has finally consumed itself.
It took Paul Tisdale to turn off the asset tap.
And now he is tasked with getting it flowing again.
That in itself, sums up where we are right now.
Our board expects the man who dismantled our player trading model in one disastrous transfer window to resurrect it again in the following one.
If that doesn’t scream at you why this board needs to go, then nothing will.
Everything now for Celtic fans is on a wing and a prayer.
We live in hope, and not much else.
2026 will either be a resounding success, or an unmitigated disaster.
I can assure you, there will be nothing in between.
Key Takeaways
- Celtic’s transfer trading model has faltered, with the board prioritising asset stripping over team support.
- Key assets like Daizen Maeda and Reo Hatate may be sold in January, leaving the squad depleted.
- The board’s past decisions have sabotaged managers and now threaten this season’s title hopes.
- Paul Tisdale’s poor recruitment has left the squad with players of little resale value and increased financial strain.
- Without winning the league, Celtic risks losing credibility and fan support, which could lead to financial disaster.














Comments.
Loading comments…