Chris Sutton wrote an extensive piece in the Record this morning.
In it, he asks a lot of questions in relation to the recent transfer window.
Questions many of us bloggers have already asked since the closure of the window last Monday.
It seems that Sutton is one of the few people in the media who wants to shoot straight from the hip on this subject.
Sutton is smart.
He is a smart pundit, and an intelligent guy to boot, with a searing wit and an ability to make a fool of someone very quickly.
He doesn’t suffer fools gladly.
And Sutton isn’t accepting the outcome of the January transfer window without questioning it either.

To be fair to him, he has been questioning our club’s behaviour in that window all throughout it anyway.
Much of what he has written this morning very much echoes my sentiments since the window closed last Monday.
He opened his article with his views on the departure of Kyogo Furuhashi:
Celtic fans seemed happy enough the other night as their team was demolishing Dundee.
Jota was back in full flow like he’d never been away, Adam Idah was bang in form and back in the goals and Daizen Maeda was doing his best Henrik Larsson impression. It was like the supporters had forgotten all about Kyogo and his departure for Rennes. That’s fair enough – but I can’t help but feel the failure to replace him is a major disappointment. Listen, Celtic are 13 points clear in the Premiership with 13 games to go. I don’t think it’s done yet but I can see why plenty of people do.
Sutton’s opening point very much reflects the general opinion in many of the comments on my blogs during the week.
Many Celtic fans out there are quite happy to accept the loss of Kyogo because we have Jota back at the club.
But, as Sutton is quick to point out, they’re missing the point.
Sutton, and I feel exactly the same myself, thinks that we have failed to build from a position of strength.
Look, I get it that there are many, many Celtic fans out there who are happy to dominate in Scotland.
They’re happy to lord it over the Ibrox side season after season, and then enjoy however far our European journey takes us each season.
Maybe they’re the realists and I’m the fantasist?
But I can’t help but feel that Celtic can and should be doing better.
Chris Sutton feels exactly the same:
The Scottish Cup is there to be won too and I’m looking at this week’s Bayern Munich game and wondering why Celtic haven’t given themselves the best possible chance of a result? We know they’re up against it. Celtic could have signed a £25million striker and still got battered by Bayern. But that’s not the point. By failing to build from a position of strength, they’ve hampered chances of causing an upset rather than improving them.
Hampered chances of causing an upset rather than improving them.
On our podcast last Tuesday evening, I pretty much said the same thing.
YouTube: The Board Failed The Manager
I felt we weren’t giving ourselves the best possible chance of winning against Bayern Munich by not replacing Kyogo.
I wrote an article yesterday evening about David Strelec, and the fact our club would not meet Slovan Bratislava’s valuation of him.
Many people commented and said he wasn’t worth what they were asking.
So his 5 goals in the Champions League this season don’t count for anything?

He could not have brought that experience to bear against Bayern Munich?
Considering the fact he has faced them already.
And the fact his side did not embarrass themselves at the Alliance Arena?
They only lost 3-1 to the Bavarian side.
Regardless, he might have strengthened our chances instead of us being weaker going into the tie.
But we’ll never know anyway, will we?
I have also made the point that there is no reason we could not have kept Kyogo until the end of the season.
I spoke about it in yesterday’s article.
Imagine my surprise then, when I then read this is Sutton’s article today:
Ask yourself, why is Kieran Tierney not at the club right now? He certainly wanted to be, rather than making five minute cameos from the Arsenal bench.
But the reason Celtic will have to wait until the summer is because Arsenal didn’t want to let him go right now and the player had to lump it. Why did that rule not apply at Celtic? If Celtic were not sure of getting a replacement, Kyogo should have been told to hold fire.
I get there was big money involved but it’s not as if money is tight at Parkhead. By letting him leave Celtic completely showed their hand. Clubs knew they badly needed a striker and would be desperate. No wonder the prices shot up. It’s rookie stuff when it comes to negotiations.
Sutton has never been one to defend our club when the board’s behaviour has been inexplicable.
The last transfer window certainly falls under the description of inexplicable.
And Sutton, just like the majority of us, believes that not replacing Kyogo was an unnecessary risk.
He also believes that our dallying in the transfer market has finally caught up with us:
As I’ve said before, it was just an unnecessary risk. And now Celtic are going to be sweating on the fitness of Idah until the end of the season – while putting a huge burden on Daizen Maeda.
The latter will be a huge loss for the Bayern game and just underlines how mystifying the window turned out. There are questions to be asked about the recruitment process at Parkhead. Celtic have left it late a few times now and it’s finally caught up with them.
As the headline of this article states, questions need to be asked about the recruitment process at Celtic Park.
But as I’ve also said, plenty of questions will be asked.
Absolutely none will be answered.
Because they never are, and as long as the current board is in place, they never will be.
This board does not believe the fans deserve to be apprised of anything that goes on at the club they invest so heavily in.
Season after season.
Michael Nicholson, after all, does not do public speaking of any description.
If he will not appear before the media, then how will he ever be subjected to questioning of any kind?
Sutton, like the rest of us, also believes that the club can do better.
We all know Celtic can do better.
Sutton believes that Brendan Rodgers is a dreamer when it comes to what his side can achieve.
But I think it’s fair to say that Rodgers this season has been an achiever, rather than a dreamer.
He has kept up his part of the bargain and delivered Champions League knockout football.
I’m sure he’s dreaming of what he can achieve against Bayern Munich, but Sutton is right in saying that we have to give ourselves the best realistic chance:
But you also have to give yourself the best realistic chance, and Celtic haven’t done that. Look, I’m not being negative. There’s a lot to like about the team right now, and they have hit form in recent weeks and they’ve made real progress in Europe. This is now about as tough as it gets. They could have done with Maeda not being banned and Kyogo on board, but that won’t be the case.
We HAVE made real progress in Europe.
But it seems some people think that it’s progress enough, whereas others don’t.
And that is the fundamental issue at Celtic Park.
It represents a lack of joined up thinking.
Until such time as there is joined up thinking, with every department working in tandem with the other, this isn’t going to change.
That’s why we ended up back at this same old juncture last Monday.
Something we thought was a thing of the past.
Now we look to the summer window, and who could blame us for having no optimism whatsoever when it comes to that?
Maybe we might be shocked.
But I won’t hold my breath.














Comments.
Loading comments…