After the cup semi-final a couple of weeks ago, I was fairly irritated with the performance by Bobby Madden. I had accepted we were not the better team on the day, but the referee’s performance still gnawed away at me.

One of my friends had spoken to me about the Netflix series, Bad Sport, which came out a few months back. He told me I should watch the one about the refereeing scandal in Italy back in the early part of the millennium. I never got around to it until Easter Sunday and I guess Bobby Madden was the reason I watched it.
I settled down to watch it that evening. The episode I watched was called Footballgate and it tells the story of the 2006 Italian refereeing scandal. After finding out that John Beaton would be the ref for Sunday’s game, I felt compelled to write this article.
Being heavily invested in Scottish football as a Celtic supporter and having experienced something far worse in our game, it was interesting to look at corruption in another league.
What I realised after watching Footballgate, is that our scandal in 2012, was far more extreme than what happened in Italy.
The difference between Scottish football’s scandal and Italian football’s, is that in Italy, they seemed to learn something from what happened.
In Scotland, absolutely nothing was learned from Rangers 1872’s collapse and liquidation in 2012.
Today, it is an anomaly, Ibrox, the SMSM and the SFA, pretend it never even happened. We all know it did, but we have a narrative rammed down our throat that it didn’t.
This is why Scottish football will never learn a lesson from it until it all blows up in our faces again.
But, to begin with, what stood out to me far more in Footballgate, was the manipulation of Italian referees by Luciano Moggi in the 2004/05 season.
This particular subject is one that is current and very raw in our own game at the moment.
After seeing how easily referees were influenced in Italy, it made me realise that it has to be far easier to influence and manipulate referees in the Scottish game.
The reason I say this is because the majority of refs in Scotland only support one team.
Added to this, we all know they do not have to declare their allegiance.
In Italy, as with in England, allegiances have to be declared.
So, as can be seen in Footballgate, they were influenced by Luciano Moggi and the heads of refereeing at the time, Paolo Bergamo and Puerluigi Pairetto.
Referees who performed poorly or did not give decisions to Juventus, found themselves refereeing games in Serie B.
Some even found themselves sacked for literally just doing their jobs and making the right calls. Pino Narducci, a public prosecutor and Attilio Auricchio, an Italian police officer, decided to take on the might of Juventus and Luciano Moggi to bring down the refereeing corruption in Italy.
But they had no idea what they were up against and as they went deeper into the underbelly of Italian football, they discovered a system of cheating so intricate, it was designed to influence games that Juventus weren’t even playing in.
Referees were told to give cards to the best players in teams that might be playing against Juventus in the next round of fixtures.
Moggi would pick out the top performing players who were on the verge of suspensions and instruct Bergamo to tell his refs to ensure they ended up suspended.
This then meant that Juventus would not have to face these players, thus increasing their chances of winning those contests.
One particular referee, Gianluca Paparesta, decided not to play ball with Moggi during a match against Reggina in December 2004.

He did not influence the game in favour of Juventus, rather he ruled out two of their goals to ensure they were defeated 2-1.
As a result, Moggi locked him into a changing room after the match, ensured his linesman was sacked and had Paparesta refereeing in Serie B the following week.

His reach in refereeing circles was huge and this is what brings me back to the game in Scotland.
Moggi was then the CEO of Juventus and at that same time, David Murray was the owner of Rangers.
Like Moggi in the Italian game, Murray’s reach was huge in the Scottish game, he practically owned the SMSM and he was deep into the EBT years then.
So let me ask this question, what level of influence, at that time, did David Murray have over the refereeing fraternity in Scotland?
Unlike Moggi, Murray had the advantage of full support from most referees in Scotland, simply because they supported his team.
The question is, how many of these referees were in his pocket?
Think about it, help the club you support and receive some nice back handers for it too.
A match that has recently re-emerged from around that time, if a little further on, is the contest between Rangers and Dundee Utd at Ibrox in May 2008. Craig Levein’s post match interview is an eye opener, his anger is there for all to see.

Clearly he was incensed at what transpired on the field of play that day and he doesn’t hold back.
It is one of those rare moments where the mask of Scottish football, for a split second, was ripped off to reveal the grotesque face of our game.
Almost immediately it was returned.
You would have thought at the time that Levein’s outburst would have been the catalyst to the floodgates opening on Scottish referees, but it wasn’t.
You would be hard pressed to find another interview like that one. Which raises the question, what happened to Levein after his outburst?
Why did we never see anything like that from him again?
Was he bought off?
He was fined €5000 for speaking his mind, did someone soften that blow to shut him up?
One thing is for sure, Scottish refereeing has not changed in the interim, if anything it’s worse.
I think we all despair at the state of our game at the moment and there doesn’t seem to be any end in sight to the corruption from the top, right down to the bottom.
VAR is a step in the right direction, but as discussed many times already, it will only be as effective as those who are put in charge of it, even that is open to corruption.
In the last ten years alone, we have seen Sevco post losses which exceed €100m. We have seen a convicted criminal become their chairman.
We have seen that same chairman receive the cold shoulder from the City of London.
We have seen countless refereeing decisions that beggar belief and continue to beggar belief, especially what we witnessed on Easter Sunday.
We have seen racism that at times makes the KKK look tame.
So, you ask, why is nothing ever done about it?
Why does it progressively get worse?
This season, at times, has descended into farce. The Cinch incident last week was just another incident in a season filled with the Ibrox side’s idiosyncratic behaviour.
It gets worse because it is systemic and our club does not have the courage to stand up to it. We might have – if Dominic McKay had remained in post – but his replacement is the ghost of Celtic past.
Never seen, never heard and the perfect torch bearer for the previous regime.
Peter Lawwell was too busy clinging to the Old Firm Inc. Premier League dream to face the scandal of 2012 head on.
Our police force did not have the courage to stand up to it and deal with it properly.
Added to that, there were too many Rangers 1872 facing officers in the Police force and that remains the case today.
The Ibrox side are seen as the establishment club and they have too many sympathisers throughout society in Scotland.
We don’t have a Pino Narducci or an Attilio Auricchio, ready to tear our corrupt game apart and take down those who allow a rabid dog like the Ibrox side go unchecked until eventually they destroy everything around them.
Until that day comes, we just have to continue to exist in stasis in a game that is rigged….














Comments.
Loading comments…