Skip to content

Sectarianism is finally compared to Anti-Semitism by BBC in the aftermath of Glasgow Derby

Share

Sectarianism is finally compared to Anti-Semitism by BBC in the aftermath of Glasgow Derby

On Sunday the 3rd of April, our game hit a seminal moment in the aftermath of events at Ibrox. Nobody wants to see scenes like we saw that day at Ibrox. But the fact is, they happened and the question that needs to be asked is this, when is enough, enough?

It cannot be said that only a small minority engaged in various different thuggish behaviours, because it was clear to all that the majority inside Ibrox on the day engaged in what could only be described as a free for all.

It is now 11 years since the billy boys was officially banned, by law, from being sung on the terraces of Scottish football grounds.

Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images News

Yet on the 3rd, all four stands in Ibrox engaged in lustily singing this horrible song. Add to that, the other unsavoury scenes involving bottle throwing, which resulted in one of Celtic’s Backroom staff being injured.

Joe Hart also ended up very lucky to escape injury and its clear to see the issues involving this club are consistently escalating, rather than improving. Finally on the 11th of April, the man responsible for throwing a bottle at one of our physios appeared in court.

Their Everyone, Anyone campaign has failed miserably in what it set out to achieve and in reality, may as well just be cast aside now. The recent Glasgow Derby scenes showed that Ibrox is certainly not a place for Everyone or Anyone.

For a long time now, our support has always spoken out about Anti-Catholic and Anti-Irish behaviour. The comparison has been made that if it was Anti-Semitic or Anti-Muslim behaviour, it would not be tolerated, nor should it be.

Yet it is and after Sunday the 3rd’s debacle, it is clear its being tolerated on an industrial scale. What is even clearer is that nobody wants to tackle this head on. As of today, still only one person has been arrested in the aftermath of Sunday’s scenes, yet almost 50,000 were allowed to break the law.

Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images Sport

So, you can imagine my surprise when I saw an article on the BBC news website, published last Friday, by none other than Chris McLaughlin, extolling the virtues of Scottish football learning lessons from German football’s fight against Anti-Semitism.

It seems an epiphany has been had in Scottish parliament and Sports minister Maree Todd believes we can learn something here, namely from Borrusia Dortmund, who have traditionally struggled with Anti-Semitic behaviour amongst their support.

Call me skeptical here, but I hate to break it to Maree Todd, we are in the year 2022 and only now she thinks there is something to learn here? Don’t get me wrong, it’s about bloody time, but as I already alluded to earlier, how long have we been talking about this for before now?

Pool/Getty Images News

Ms. Todd believes much can be learned from Borussia Dortmund, saying:

“I think it is still a problem – I think it’s a problem in our society and it’s a problem in football,” said Ms Todd.

“I have met recently with representatives of Borussia Dortmund who have had an amazing programme where, from the grassroots up, they have looked to change their culture of anti-Semitism.

“Over 10 years they have had some real successes with that programme and they’re now using it to tackle other equalities issues. “They have had a problem in their city and in their football club and they’ve really turned it around.”

All well and good, but there is a huge difference between Anti-Semitism and Sectarianism, Anti-Catholic and Anti-Irish racism. Post War in Germany, the country was left with no choice but to clean up its act when it came to Anti-Semitism.

The BBC News article refers to Sectarianism as Scotland’s secret shame. Newsflash, it isn’t a well kept secret. The whole world knew about the Ibrox club’s signing policy up until 1989. We’re also acutely aware that Sectarianism is a key word in Scotland, used to describe much more than just “Sectarianism”. Most of you reading this will know exactly what I mean.

Many laws were introduced to deter Anti-Semitism and the difference between Germany and Scotland when it comes to enforcement of laws in this regard, is stark. While Scotland has introduced laws to deter Sectarianism, it cannot be said they are being enforced to any great degree.

Pool/Getty Images Sport

I think the fact that 50,000 people were allowed to fly in the face of the law on Sunday the 3rd, pretty much speaks volumes about the distance that has to be covered to even begin to tackle this problem. It makes you wonder what to expect on Sunday for the Cup semi final?

Is a showpiece at the national stadium – a day that should be promoting the Scottish game to the world – going to be marred by one half of the stadium singing about being up to their knees in the blood of the people in other half of the stadium?

While it’s nice to wax lyrical about learning from Borussia Dortmund, the reality is that there’s a willingness to tackle Anti-Semitism at their club. The same cannot be said for the Ibrox club. In fact its the total opposite, the board there panders to the worst elements of their support and if anything, runs scared from it.

Ms. Todd also talks about strict liability in the article, something which I and many other fans, are strongly against. Introduce strict liability and everybody suffers. Why should every other club have to suffer for the sins of one?

Last summer, a Greek journalist hit the nail on the head when he said:

“Scotland does not have a Sectarian problem, it has a ‘R***ers’ problem”.

I think Ms. Todd would do well to heed that headline, because unlike the SMSM, journalists outside Scotland have no problem calling this what it really is.

The question is, will the learnings from Borrusia Dortmund be applied to the Ibrox club? I won’t hold my breath. There is no willingness to change at Ibrox and in reality, who would implement such a change without actually having to enforce it?

In Germany, from 1945 onward, there were serious consequences for those who engaged in Anti-Semitism. It is 2022 and the Ibrox club still behaves with impunity. If there are no consequences for your behaviour, then how will you ever change it?

50,000 law breakers, one arrest. I rest my case.

When is enough, enough?

Jump to comments

Eric Knott began his career as a football blogger in 2021. Having been an avid supporter of Celtic football club for the majority of his life, Eric had been following all of the major Celtic blogs in the blogosphere before fan media had the kind of impact that it has now. In September of 2021, Eric launched his own independent blog called, McCuttaway, the cutting edge on all things Celtic. From the off, his blogs garnered a lot of interest, consistently trending alongside the work of well established Celtic blogging websites. As a result, in early 2022, Eric's work brought him to the attention, via another well know blogger, of the owners of the Read network, who offered him a position as a writer on Read Celtic, where he has been writing since April of 2022. Now well established as a Celtic blogger, Eric also works on a podcast with two other well known Celtic bloggers from the VideoCelts website, and The Celtic Blog website. You can find his blogs daily on Read Celtic, and the Trinity Tims podcast can be found weekly on Youtube.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.