Skip to content

Celtic should look at Lundstram as McCarthy alternative [Opinion]

Share

Celtic should look at Lundstram as McCarthy alternative [Opinion]

Celtic have reportedly registered their interest in Crystal Palace midfielder James McCarthy over recent days.

That’s according to Football Insider, who claim that Celtic may have to wait until the summer to seal a deal for the boyhood Hoops fan.

McCarthy, 30, is out of contract at Selhurst Park at the end of the current campaign.

However, we think the Hoops should be looking at Sheffield United’s John Lundstram as an alternative option to McCarthy.


Lundstram, four years McCarthy’s junior, is also out of contract at the end of the season, with both players available to discuss pre-contract terms with clubs outside of England.

The Blades midfielder has made twice as many appearances as McCarthy in the Premier League this season, boasting better average stats in numerous departments.

Lundstram has averaged 1.1 sprints per game, 1.1 key passes per 90 and 0.7 successful dribbles, way clear of McCarthy‘s 0.1, 0.1 and 0.3 respectively. [WhoScored]

The Englishman’s pass success percentage (84.4%) is also streets ahead of the Irishman this season (68.1%)

In terms of finances, Lunstram also appears the smarter move. He’s reportedly on just £4,000-a-week at Bramall Lane, compared to McCarthy’s huge £50,000-a-week pay packet.

Finally, we feel as if the Hoops have to think about the long-term picture at Parkhead.

Lundstram, who was described as having ‘all the attributes’ by teammate Billy Sharp last year, appears to be in the prime of his career.

Meanwhile, McCarthy seems a bit-part player under Roy Hodgson, so the Hoops might not get the Irishman at his best. To us, Lundstram over McCarthy is a no-brainer and one that the club should look at getting over the line.

Jump to comments

Freelance football writer. Leeds United fan

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.