Skip to content

Take the money for Olivier Ntcham? Be careful what you wish for!

Share

Take the money for Olivier  Ntcham? Be careful what you wish for!

Midway through the January transfer window, Celtic supporters will be pleased with the early business. Timothy Weah and Oliver Burke have added some attacking firepower for the remainder of the season whilst Vakoun Issouf Bayo looks to be the man to fill the big boots of Moussa Dembele.

With virtually a new front three in the door already, Brendan Rodgers and the Celtic board will undoubtedly be turning their attention to defensive areas. The need for a new right-back for example, is there for all to see.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

Before ranting on about Celtic’s Swedish full back, there needs to be a discussion around the future of Frenchman Olivier Ntcham.

Reports this week have mentioned interest from Porto, who have been admirers of the midfielder since the summer. Talk of a £14million bid, along with the possibility of defender Chancel Mbemba moving the opposite way to Glasgow, has sent some fans back to the excitement of Christmas. But hold on!

Like many of his teammates, Ntcham’s Ibrox outing last month didn’t cover the Frenchman in much glory and it seemed the month of December wasn’t his greatest as he had dip in form whilst others around him, like Ryan Christie and Callum McGregor, excelled.

However, turn your attention back to September, in the last meeting with Rangers and the 22-year-old bagged the winner in an outstanding display as his side won 1-0.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

Ntcham joined Celtic from Manchester City last summer in a deal worth £4.5 million, the biggest sum for a player afforded to Rodgers since the record permanent deal for Odsonne Edouard last June.

In of his 78 appearances for the club, Ntcham has contributed 15 goals including three decisive winners. In his six Scottish cup outings, he has netted three times and bagged an assist, including strikes against Rangers in the semi-final and Celtic’s all-important second goal in the 2-0 victory over Motherwell in the final.

Continuing his big-game performances, Ntcham has chipped in with goals in the early European qualifiers, with one to settle the nerves away in Astana last season, a lovely curling goal against Rosenborg at Parkhead this term and the away goal against FK Suduva as his side reached the Europa League group stages.

Even with his important contributions, a bid of £14 million is understandably tempting, especially with other areas of the squad needing investment. However, based on previous cases, investment is no guarantee.

Moussa Dembele left for £19.7 million in the summer after Stuart Armstrong raised a £7 million transfer fee. A rather hefty income. In addition, there is the bonus that we heard so much about from Virgil van Dijk’s sell on clause after his £75 million move to Liverpool from Southampton.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

Since these departures, you wouldn’t be far off to say that the Celtic board have failed to replace these quality players, especially with the money that has reportedly come in.

The disappointment of the summer window has been mentioned enough but unfortunately, I’m going to delve back into it!

John McGinn (yes him again!) was a clear target for Rodgers but the Scottish champions were beaten to a deal by Aston Villa in the English Championship after they bid around £3 million, a price that was apparently too high for the Celtic board, despite raking in more than double that from the sale of Armstrong.

Whilst I am pleased with the capture of Vakoun Issouf Bayo and believe the in-form youngster will come good in Scotland, he cost Celtic around 10 per cent of the money made from Dembele. There must be more in the transfer kitty, but will it be used?

Talk of a Victor Wanyama return seems unlikely, even for the most optimistic of Celtic fans, but you again wonder where the money from his £13 million sale went to?

The purchase of Marvin Compper perhaps?

If Ntcham was to leave, it’s very wishful thinking to imagine a good proportion of the cash actually being spent. James McCarthy could be one that would come in to replace him on a six-month loan deal, talk about building for the future!

A 28-year-old for the short term or a rising French under-21 player who recently penned a new four-year deal. I know which one I would take every time.

Stu Forster/Getty Images Sport

The huge excitement around a defender like Mbemba being part of the deal is another worry for me. Such expectation around a pretty random centre-half all stems from the complete lack of a solid defensive partnership in the two and half years Rodgers has been at the club.

From Erik Sviatchenko to Jozo Simunovic, and even now the success of Dedryck Boyata and Filip Benkovic won’t last longer than this season.  Another clear lack of investment.

But £9 million was splashed to sign Edouard you’ll no doubt say? And you’d be right. An exciting deal for a raw talent, who will improve but this one deal for one player only papers over the recruitment cracks.

Such recruitment issues are summed up by the return of Emilio Izaguirre, a former player who was clearly the best option after scouting the most suitable left backs throughout world football…

Spending big isn’t part of Celtic’s so-called transfer model, so why do it with Edouard and then not look to kick on and move up a level.

Rodgers has previously stated the importance of the January window in preparing for the hugely important Champions League qualifiers that get Celtic’s season underway.

Last year, January saw Marvin Compper, Jack Hendry, Charly Musonda and Scott Bain come in. Bain has looked a solid acquisition whilst the Musonda deal didn’t really work out, however, the two defenders, Compper with his 83-minute show in particular, have been nothing short of disastrous.

The current squad has the potential of going into these crucial qualifiers even WEAKER than last year. Frankly, that is criminal.

Even this year, by preparing for these early games, Celtic have signed two players on loan deals, who return to their parent clubs before then. Would a successful six months form Oliver Burke lead to Celtic splashing some cash to bring him to Parkhead permanently? Again, I wouldn’t hold out much hope.

Going back to Mikael Lustig. The 32-year-old has been on a clear decline for a while now. Celtic need a quality right-back. Celtic have the money for a quality right-back so therefore in this window, that is the bare minimum for the board or they could pay a heavy price.

The manager has delivered seven consecutive trophies in his time at Celtic, the sheer refusal to back him in some transfers is mind-blowing. As his squad seems to get weaker and weaker, his counterpart over in Govan has been backed with 16 completed deals in his first season in charge. A title-race, however unlikely it seemed or should have been, is most definitely on.

Ian MacNicol/Getty Images Sport

This current transfer approach is not only risking the league title and Champions League football in the future but it’s risking the club’s manager. Something that has to change.

Jump to comments

Sports Journalism Student.Celtic FC.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.