Skip to content

Celtic penalty outrage – McInnes and Boyd’s staggering double standards exposed

Share

Celtic penalty outrage – McInnes and Boyd’s staggering double standards exposed

Derek McInnes described Celtic’s controversial Motherwell penalty as “disgusting” in May. He suggested his Hearts side were fighting against everybody.

Yet when the Ibrox club benefited from a disputed penalty against St Mirren earlier this month, the Rangers manager’s response was considerably more restrained.

McInnes praised his team’s performance and acknowledged that the penalty and a deflected goal had helped secure their victory.

And when you add Kris Boyd’s remarkable changes of opinion on Sky Sports, a familiar question returns.

Why does the outrage seem so much louder when Celtic benefit?

Celtic penalty sparked McInnes fury

Celtic’s dramatic 3-2 victory at Motherwell in May kept their title hopes alive.

Kelechi Iheanacho converted a stoppage-time penalty following a VAR review of Sam Nicholson’s handball.

McInnes, then Hearts manager, was furious.

As BBC Sport documented, he described the decision as disgusting and claimed Hearts were up against everybody.

His comments subsequently earned him a disciplinary suspension, which Rangers successfully appealed in part.

The Scottish FA’s Key Match Incident panel later ruled that Celtic’s penalty should not have been awarded.

That finding justified criticism of the decision. It did not justify suggestions of deliberate favouritism.

Boyd’s convenient change of principles

Kris Boyd’s reactions were arguably even more revealing.

Just ten days before Motherwell, Celtic had complained about a controversial Hibernian equaliser.

Boyd’s message on Sky Sports was that supporters should trust the technology and officials.

Reasonable advice.

Until Celtic benefited.

Following the Motherwell penalty, Boyd questioned the decision and brought other incidents involving Celtic into the discussion.

Suddenly, trusting the officials wasn’t quite so straightforward.

Where was that calm perspective from the previous week?

Apparently, it had disappeared along with Celtic’s misfortune.

Rangers penalty produces a different reaction

Then came Rangers’ 2-0 victory over St Mirren on 7 November.

James Penrice went down following Samuel Ramos’s challenge. Nick Walsh awarded a penalty, and Ryan Naderi converted.

St Mirren questioned the consistency of the decision.

Yet McInnes was happy to discuss the performance and the importance of three points.

As The Scotsman reported, McInnes acknowledged that Rangers had scored through a penalty and a deflection.

No dramatic allegations about Scottish football being against anybody.

Meanwhile, Boyd’s Sky Sports response was notably relaxed, even resorting to a comparison involving soft-boiled and hard-boiled eggs.

Quite a contrast to his forensic examination of Celtic’s decisions.

Celtic deserve one standard

Let’s be clear. The Motherwell and St Mirren penalties were different incidents, involving different refereeing judgments.

But that’s not the central issue.

The issue is the language, the outrage and the willingness to accept officials’ decisions.

When Celtic suffer, we’re told to trust referees.

When Celtic benefit, every controversial incident becomes another chapter in some grand conspiracy.

When the Ibrox club benefit, suddenly nuance and understanding return.

Nobody wants special treatment for Celtic.

We simply want the same standards applied to everybody.

And until that happens, supporters will continue questioning the remarkable hypocrisy surrounding Scottish football.

Key takeaways

  • McInnes strongly criticised Celtic’s Motherwell penalty in May.
  • The SFA panel subsequently ruled the award incorrect.
  • Boyd urged trust in officials after Celtic’s Hibernian grievance.
  • Boyd’s later criticism of Celtic decisions contrasted with that advice.
  • Rangers’ disputed St Mirren penalty prompted noticeably calmer reactions.

Further reading

Jump to comments

Phil Cooney I'm 52 years old and from Coatbridge, and Celtic has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Supporting the club isn't just a hobby for me – it's part of who I am. My first visit to Celtic Park came in 1985 against St Mirren, and from that day I was hooked. Like so many supporters of my generation, I grew up idolising Paul McStay. His loyalty, class and ability made him my favourite player, and he remains the player who best represents what Celtic means to me. The Centenary Season will always hold a special place in my heart. Watching Billy McNeill lead the club to that unforgettable league title is a memory I'll never forget, and it's still the benchmark for what Celtic should strive to be. Through this site I write as a supporter first and foremost. I'll praise the club when praise is deserved, but I won't shy away from questioning decisions or expressing concerns when I believe standards have slipped. My aim is to offer honest opinions, thoughtful analysis and passionate discussion on everything happening at Celtic. Whether it's transfer news, match analysis, or the bigger issues surrounding the club, I write from the perspective of someone who has lived and breathed Celtic for over four decades. Hail Hail.

View all articles →

Comments.

Sign in with your account to join the discussion.Sign in

Loading comments…

Related Stories.